Skip to content
Teaching and Education Research

An international forum for rigorous research on teaching, learning and teacher education

Research articleOpen access

Differentiating instruction: Understanding the key elements for successful teacher preparation and development

Show affiliations and correspondence
  1. aAmsterdam University of Applied Sciences; University of Amsterdam
  2. bUniversity of Amsterdam
  3. cErasmus University Rotterdam

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2023.104464

Outline

Abstract

Primary and secondary school teachers are expected to adapt their teaching to the diverse educational needs of students through differentiated instruction (DI). This review included 29 peer-reviewed published articles from 2010 to 2020 evaluating the contribution of preservice and in-service teacher programs for DI. We synthesized program components, outcomes and contextual interplay. Results indicate that successful programs incorporate active learning, collaboration and reflection and were often longitudinal, comprehensive and addressed attitudes, knowledge and skills. Contextual (school) factors acted as facilitators and impediments to program efficacy. Balancing school ambitions with realistic expectations is a concern. Educational and policy implications are further discussed.

1. Introduction

Diversity in education is indisputable, and differences between students are inherent in classroom contexts (Belfi et al., 2012). This applies even more to urban environments where there is often a heterogeneous student population in terms of sociocultural backgrounds, home environments and languages and countless related characteristics that influence the quality of life and the dynamics of power and privilege (Gaikhorst, 2014; Matsko & Hammerness, 2014). This calls on teachers to optimize the growth of each student by accepting and recognizing that students have different ways of learning and responding to instruction (Gay, 2018; Tomlinson, 2014). Differentiated instruction (DI) is a comprehensive teaching approach that intends to maximize the learning outcomes of all students in the classroom and decrease the achievement gap (Denessen, 2017; Gheyssens et al., 2020; Griful-- Freixenet et al., 2020; Steenbergen-Hu et al., 2016).

While most teachers espouse these anticipated benefits of DI in meeting student needs, its actual adoption in practice by teachers is considered a major challenge and remains critical (Suprayogi et al., 2017). Teachers often need additional preparation and practice to be equipped for implementing DI in their classrooms (Dixon et al., 2014). For the last decade in particular, we have seen an increase in efforts aimed at developing and monitoring programs to effectively prepare and equip teachers for this task (Parsons et al., 2018). Even though the growing body of literature on DI offers some starting points, there is still no consensus on how to effectively prepare and professionalize teachers for DI (Bondie et al., 2019; Deunk et al., 2018; Smets, 2019).

The present review study aims to uncover and describe what the literature tells us about teacher preparation and training programs targeted at improving teachers’ competence for tailoring their education to the diverse learning needs of students.

1.1. Differentiated instruction

DI is a philosophy and praxis of teaching and learning rooted in the acknowledgment of student differences and aimed at tailoring instruction to support each student’s growth and development (Deunk et al., 2018). In the research literature, DI initially focused on teaching for gifted students, then evolved into a set of instructional practices aimed at special education inclusion classrooms, and further developed into a mainstream teaching approach for meeting the needs of all learners in regular classrooms (Graham et al., 2021; Stradling & Saunders, 1993). This widespread adoption of DI has concurrently given rise to a proliferation of concepts and strategies (Bondie et al., 2019). Therefore the concept can be characterized by a degree of ambiguity and lack of clear-cut definition (Deunk et al., 2018; Graham et al., 2021; Smets & Struyven, 2018; Van Geel et al., 2019).

Although DI is not precisely * Corresponding author. Faculty of Education, Amsterdam University of Applied Sciences, Wibautstraat 2–4, 1091 GM, Amsterdam, Netherlands. 2delineated and unambiguously operationalized in the literature, there is an emergent understanding of its comprehensive characteristics. Jager et al. (2022) identified both deliberateness and adaptiveness as common ground when responding to differences between learners in the heterogeneous classroom. Tomlinson and Imbeau (2010) argued that the core of DI is the teacher’s adaptation of content, process, product and affect in response to perceived differences in learners’ readiness, interests, and learning profile. This involves teachers recognizing students’ learning needs, adjusting learning objectives, curriculum content, instructional methods, learning tasks, and ongoing assessment of student development (Prast et al., 2015; Van Geel et al., 2019).

DI is supported by a positive attitude towards diversity and the recognition of students’ diverse backgrounds, encompassing students with varying levels of academic readiness, diverse cultural backgrounds, and a range of learning abilities (Gay, 2010; Wilkinson & Penney, 2014). To provide a clear delineation of DI for this review, we define it as a proactive approach that incorporates inclusive strategies to create tailored, accessible learning experiences that meet the educational needs of all students within the classroom.

1.1.1. Research on the impact of DI

The literature provides indications that DI positively impacts students’ learning outcomes. Deunk et al. (2018) identified a modest positive impact of DI on student performance in primary education. In secondary education, research revealed small to moderate effects of DI on learning outcomes (Smale-Jacobse et al., 2019). Steenbergen-Hu et al. (2016) demonstrated in their second-order meta-analysis, that student learning outcomes benefited from within-class ability grouping, a closely aligned teaching approach. DI can also impacts students’ social and emotional development, as Pozas et al. (2020) indicated. In addition to these potential benefits of DI and its substantial premises, it is relevant to consider some limitations of research on DI, as pointed out by Smale-Jacobse et al. (2019) and Graham et al. (2021).

The diffuse conceptualization of DI, the different processes and procedures used in providing it, and the paucity of details regarding teacher professionalization for implementing DI collectively highlight the importance of critically exploring this area and suggest that a study of ways to support teachers in learning about and implementing DI is warranted.

1.1.2. Knowledge, skills, and attitudes for DI

DI can be understood as a teacher competency, that is, an integrated set of knowledge, skills and attitudes (Keuning et al., 2017; Korthagen, 2004). This presumes that developing teacher competence for DI necessitates the consideration of teachers’ knowledge, skills, and attitudes. Implementing DI requires from teachers to know when and how to teach specific content effectively and to have knowledge of approaches that enable pupils to be taught effectively (Smets, 2019). When teachers integrate knowledge about DI into their existing knowledge frameworks about teaching and learning, this can strengthen DI implementation (Van Geel et al., 2022). Since the transfer of knowledge about DI to practice is often challenging, it is recommended that teacher development programs pay explicit attention to the implementation process (Gheyssens et al., 2020).

Effectiveness of DI primarily hinges on the teacher’s actions, specifically, how they deliberately, proactively, and effectively adapt instruction to meet the diverse learning needs of their students, for example by adapting materials for diverse learners and using appropriate instructional strategies (Tomlinson et al., 2003; Van Geel et al., 2019). The initial step in achieving this is the development of skills. Practical classroom experience stands out as the most advantageous factor for DI skill development (Van Geel et al., 2022). Teacher self-efficacy positively impacts the implementation of DI and is reinforced by classroom experience with DI (Dixon et al., 2014). Teacher qualities for DI extend beyond teacher knowledge and practical skills, as attitudes also play a crucial role.

Teacher attitudes toward immigrant and marginalized students have been shown to lessen teachers’ expectations, both those they have of themselves to be effective teachers and those they have of their pupils (Rubie-Davies, 2010). These expectations steer and deeply affect the way teachers behave toward their students, which is subsequently perceived by students and to which they respond in terms of behavior and school performance (Denessen, 2017; Dweck, 2015). Dweck (2015) argued that a growth mindset should be developed for teachers to believe that most student learning can be achieved through dedication and hard work. From this viewpoint, every student is capable of being successful, which emphasizes and fosters the teacher’s responsibility for the learning of all students in the classroom.

According to this perspective, teacher attitudes act as a filter for knowledge, influence the formulation of a problem or task, and guide teacher’s intent and actions in the classroom (Fives and Buehl, 2008). Critically reflecting on one’s own beliefs and how these beliefs influence their instructional behaviors can challenge and alter these beliefs, providing an impetus to change teacher behavior (Akiba, 2011; Gay, 2010).

1.2. Teacher development for DI

Implementing DI is a complex matter in which multiple types of knowledge, skills and attitudes are intertwined in an integrated way (Van Geel et al., 2022). There are numerous indicators that both preservice and in-service teachers should be guided and supported in the effective development of DI competence (Eysink et al., 2017; Feiman-Nemser, 2001; Gaikhorst, 2014; Matsko et al., 2022; Ruys et al., 2012; Van Geel et al., 2019).

1.2.1. Teacher preparation for DI

Maulana et al. (2015) stressed the complexity of DI and indicated that effectively developing competencies for DI takes time and that basic teaching skills are considered a prerequisite. Other studies emphasized the importance of paying attention to DI as early as during teacher education, because (1) knowledge and skills gained during initial teacher education would be key to successful implementation of differentiation, and (2) it allows DI to be presented as the standard teaching approach, rather than introducing it later as an additional and complementary approach (Brevik et al., 2018; D’Intino & Wang, 2021; Dee, 2010; De Neve & Devos, 2016; Matsko & Hammerness, 2014; Scarparolo & Subban, 2021; Specht et al., 2016; Van Geel et al., 2022; Wertheim & Leyser, 2002).

Although teacher education programs meet the demands placed on them by addressing DI in their curricula, they often offer only an introduction to theory (D’Intino & Wang, 2021). This cursory introduction to differentiation is a start, but may not provide enough depth to support teachers to effectively put DI into practice.

1.2.2. Teacher professional development for DI

Ongoing professional development throughout in-service teachers’ careers is considered indispensable for teachers to (learn to) respond well to the learning needs of their students (Gheyssens et al., 2020; Smets, 2019; Van Geel et al., 2019). TPD initiatives encompass processes and activities designed to improve teachers’ classroom practices, with a consequential impact on student learning outcomes (Guskey, 2002; van Veen et al., 2012). The overarching goal is to create a diverse and effective teaching force that can adapt to the changing needs of students and teaching. Professional development opportunities for in-service teachers are often provided by educational consultants who have acquired expertise in DI.

TPD offerings take many different formats and range from a half-day PD to a long term sustained program. Most schools do not have access to extensive programs, due to limited resources or other considerations (Sims & Fletcher-Wood, 2021). Kahmann et al. (2022) conducted a meta-analysis providing an overview of characteristics and effectiveness of 27 (quasi-) experimental studies focused on DI and revealed a medium effect of such programs on teacher measures. They furthermore exposed a need for more explicit statements about the programs theory of improvement to support effective evaluation and B.N. Langelaan et al. 3enable better-informed program adjustments.

1.2.3. Effectiveness of teacher professional development

Over the past two decades, researchers have identified components of teacher professional development (TPD) that may bring about positive change in teacher attitudes, knowledge, and skills (Borko, 2004; Darling-Hammond et al., 2017; Guskey, 2003; van Veen et al., 2012). Specifically, Darling-Hammond et al. (2017) reviewed 35 methodologically rigorous studies that demonstrated positive links between TPD and teacher practice and identified effective TPD characteristics. According to Darling-Hammond et al. (2017) effective TPD is (1) content focused, (2) incorporates active learning strategies, (3) supports structured teacher collaboration, (4) makes use of models and modeling of effective practice, (5) integrates coaching and support of experts, and (6) provides opportunities for feedback and reflection.

The (limited) success of TPD in DI is often associated with the opportunities and constraints for successful implementation provided by the context of the program (Gaitas & Alves Martins, 2017; Sims & Fletcher-Wood, 2021; Suprayogi et al., 2017; Van Geel et al., 2022). Desimone (2009) provided a conceptual framework for research on effective TPD that presents core features of effective TPD and incorporates context as an important mediator and moderator influencing the professional development of teachers.

1.3. Present study and research questions

The purpose of the current study is to build on previous research and explore the components, ingredients and contextual integration of TPD related to DI. This is further specified in the following research questions: (1) which components do current teacher programs for DI contain? (2) what are effective ingredients of teacher programs for DI, and (3) which contextual factors influence the success of teacher programs for DI?

2. Methodology and methods

The objective of this descriptive review is to provide a comprehensive and detailed synthesis of studies on the effects of DI teacher training programs, aimed at providing a deeper understanding of effective key elements. The reporting is in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Review and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement. By analyzing relevant research on DI teacher training programs, we seek to understand the breadth and depth of the existing body of studies and identify gaps that need to be explored. In doing so, the steps of Xiao and Watson (2019) were followed: (1) literature search, (2) screening for inclusion (3) quality assessment, (4) extracting data and (5) analysis.

These steps aim to systematically assess the content and methodology of the collected studies and contribute to a well-structured and robust assessment process.

In light of the observation of Parsons et al. (2018) that researchers turned to professional development in DI as a research topic around the year 2010, we considered studies focused on the evaluation of preservice and in-service teacher programs for DI published between 2010 and 2020. A search syntax (see Fig. 1) was formulated to systematically browse the three commonly used databases within the field of educational research (ERIC, PsycINFO and Web of Science). The trial search was repeatedly checked against already known primary studies that belong in the set (Kitchenham & Charters, 2007). The search syntax used was composed of terms for DI, e.g.: ‘differentiation’, ‘individualized’, ‘adaptive’, ‘situated’, ‘culturally responsive’, These were combined (AND) with terms for ‘teacher education’, ‘preservice teacher education’, ‘teacher training’, ‘professional development’ and ‘professional learning’.

An asterisk (*) was used as a wildcard.

2.2. Screening for inclusion and quality assessment

Aiming at systematic reporting, a Prisma flowchart (see Fig. 2) was used to depict the flow of information through the different selection phases of included studies. (Moher et al., 2009). Initially, 4917 publications were identified (n = 3698 unique publications after removing duplicates using Zotero software). Backward reference searching resulted in three more articles. This strategy was used to ensure comprehensive coverage of the relevant literature by identifying relevant studies that were not included in the databases searched or our search terms were not present in the title, abstract, or keywords. To narrow our selection, we uploaded the documents’ abstracts in the Rayyan QCRI web application which scoped the abstracts of n = 3701 documents.

Rayyan QCRI enables to collaboratively assess a large volume of articles systematically, enhances efficiency and reduces the risk of human errors. Table 1 lists the inclusion and exclusion criteria. We included studies based on the following inclusion criteria: (1) the publication was available in the English language; (2) the study was published in peerreviewed scholarly journals 2010–2020; (3) the program was aimed at primary or secondary school teachers. Early childhood and kindergarten were excluded for reasons of comparability; (4) the program targeted Fig. 1. Search strategies for electronic databases. B.N. Langelaan et al. 4preservice and/or in-service teachers; and (5) the outcome variables reflected DI.

We aimed at generic approaches to DI (and approaches that can be deployed as such) and excluded studies focused on specific subject-related didactic approaches, for example on language teaching, that do not belong within the focus of this review. The studies (n = 3701) titles, abstracts and subject headings (if available) were screened based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Potentially eligible studies (n = 233) were obtained in full text and evaluated to determine study eligibility. We removed 188 studies, and, for reasons of reliability, 45 studies were assessed for eligibility by two researchers. These researchers conducted independent reviews of the 45 manuscripts in parallel, reading the full text using the criteria for inclusion.

Discrepancies were discussed and resolved. After collaborative deliberation, studies considered outside the scope were excluded from the sample. A total of 32 studies were deemed appropriate for quality assessment. To reassure and refine the credibility and trustworthiness of the findings, the Critical Appraisal Skills Programme (CASP) (2019) checklist for qualitative research, an appraisal tool that systematically checks the research’s value, was used. Even though not all the studies were of a qualitative nature, this tool was considered useful for all studies to assess the approach in terms of validity, outcomes and relevance. Full texts were evaluated for quality by the first author. Debatable cases were rescreened by at least two researchers and discussed in the research team, and it was jointly decided which articles to include.

The final sample of included outputs consisted of 29 primary studies.

2.3. Extraction and analysis

The 29 articles were coded using a qualitative data analysis software program (MAXQDA). Research team consultations led to refinement of the coding structure. The selection of meaningful text passages and interpretations of their meaning were systematically verified for reasons of accountability. First, for each study, the formal reference was annotated (author, journal, country), the target group, the program’s aim(s) and outcome measures: teacher knowledge, skills, attitude or student performance. If there was a positive effect of a training program (measured or observed improvement), the results of a study were categorized with a ‘+’. If there was a partially positive effect (an improvement on certain aspects but not on others) then the results of a study were categorized with a ‘+/ ’.

If no or negative effects were reported after a program, the outcomes were categorized with ’-’. It is important to note that qualitative studies often reported different outcome measures, such as changes in participants’ perspectives or teachers’ reported experiences. The coding of the program components was grounded in a theoretical framework of effective general teacher professionalization by Darling-Hammond et al. (2017), who built on extensive literature. The categories and subcategories presented in Table 2 were developed through a multi-step process that involved both deductive and inductive approaches. We started with this theoretical framework as a foundation and adapted the initial coding framework to the specific context of our study.

This adaptation involved revising, adding, or combining codes to better align with the findings from the data collected from the primary studies. Multiple rounds of reading and re-reading put forward new subcategories and definitions. To enhance the validity and reliability of the coding process, multiple researchers were involved. Discrepancies were resolved through discussion and consensus-building. For the coding of the program context, the model of Desimone (2009) was used, which makes a distinction between contextual factors that relate to the school (type, physical environment, school culture, leadership, policy, collaboration and support structures) and to the teacher (s) (prior knowledge, teacher qualities).

When program context was explicitly mentioned as of supposed influence on the program’s success, it was included in the results section of this study. Contextual factors were classified as facilitators if it was stated that the contextual factor positively influenced the program’s effect or success. The studies were Fig. 2. Prisma flow chart (based on Moher et al., 2009). Table 1 Inclusion and exclusion criteria. Inclusion criteria Exclusion criteria Publications in English language area Outside English language areas Peer-reviewed articles and working papers 2010–2020 Conference papers and dissertations Primary and secondary school Nontarget f.e. early childhood, disabled, elderly Preservice, and in-service teachers Outside area of teacher training/ professionalization Differentiation, adaptive teaching, culturally responsive teaching Other teaching skills B.N.

Langelaan et al. 5classified as barriers if the factor negatively influenced the program’s effect or success. Quotes from the studies were added to illustrate the results. To enforce systematic and transparent coding, we conducted an approach where the coding of passages was also performed by another researcher (Miles et al., 2014). Any differences were discussed in the research team until consensus was reached and the coding was adjusted to reflect the outcome of this discussion. For rigor of the analysis, approximately 10% of the final coding of fragments were rated by two raters and the interrater reliability measure (Cohens k) (Moher et al., 2009) revealed a near perfect interrater agreement in interpretation (k = 0.88).

3. Results

The programs for DI in the sample targeted both preservice (13) and in-service (15) teachers (see Table 3). One study used a combined focus on both target groups. Most studies focused on secondary education (17), and a smaller number focused on primary education (7) or a combination of (preservice) primary and secondary education (4). The final sample of outputs (29) consisted of 18 qualitative, two quantitative and nine mixed methods studies. Twelve studies in the sample can be regarded as process oriented and intended to describe how DI learning Table 2 Classification of program components. Main category and components Abbv. Brief description Content focus Teacher issues IS Focus on daily issues and concerns of teachers in the specific context in which they operate Student learning SL Focus on specific student populations with targeted strategies to support student achievement Active learning Practice in design PD Design of lesson plans or teaching strategies Simulation-Based Learning PS Engagement with content in role play or otherwise amplified real experience Practice in Classroom PC Implementation of learning content in actual classrooms with students Classroom Inquiry IQ Constructing, trying out, and reflecting on new teaching strategies Collaboration Collaboration with peers CP One-on-one or small-group interactions with colleagues or other professionals beyond the school Collaboration with students CS Structured collaborative activities with (prospective) students Use of Models and modeling Curricular Models CM Provision of a vision of practice through, e.g., student work samples or demonstration lesson plans Modeling of Instruction MI Provision of a vision of practice by engaging teachers in demonstration lessons with effective instruction Coaching and Expert Support Coaching CA Guiding and facilitating learning in the context of practice Expert instruction EX Sharing of content, evidencebased practice and expertise Feedback and Reflection Reflection RF Provision of time and opportunity for teachers to think about, receive input on, and make changes to teacher practice Feedback FB Redirecting or refocusing teachers’ practice to thoughtfully move to expert visions of practice Table 3 Program specifications, descriptions and objectives.

Study Geographical setting Target group Teacher training program description and objectives Acquah (2020) Finland Preservice teachers Twelve weeks; modeling of culturally responsive teaching strategies and activities, including line-up games, group discussions, critical reflection, writing autobiographies, and structured field experiences combined with postexperience reflection Achieve transformative learning manifest by reevaluating stereotypes, misconceptions and teacher beliefs Assaf (2015) United States Preservice teachers Primary school Six months; servicelearning project and fieldbase TE program Scaffold prospective teachers to become culturally responsive in their teaching Dack (2018; 2019; 2020) United States Preservice teachers Secondary school Fourteen weeks; explicit modeling meetings, wholegroup and small-group discussion, and workshops Develop knowledge of and attitudes toward (Tomlinson’s model of) differentiated instruction Duquette (2016) Canada Preservice teachers Primary school Nine weeks; (preparatory) SE course, guided reflection questions on used strategies and weekly discussions on possible solutions Develop personal and practical knowledge about students and refine DI practices Goodnough (2010) Canada Preservice teachers Secondary school Biweekly sessions and a three-week learning block.

Short readings, content input and models. Inquisitive collaborative work on messy, open-ended problems concerning DI Explore the principles of DI and how these principles could be translated into classroom practice Kuehl (2018) United States Preservice teachers Primary school Six weeks; simulated experience of one-on-one conferencing while receiving peer support Learn to practice differentiated instruction LaBelle (2016) United States, the Preservice teachers Secondary school Eight weeks; lectures and structured reflective assignments Support the development of teacher beliefs Seglem and Garcia (2015) United States Preservice teachers Secondary school Structured meetings in a shared virtual space Increase understanding of urban students and develop teacher beliefs toward student learning Wan (2015) Hong Kong Preservice teachers Primary and secondary school Thirteen weeks; sessions providing theories and practical implications, workshops, professional sharing by experts, in-class and online group (continued on next page) B.N.

Langelaan et al. 6Table 3 (continued ) Study Geographical setting Target group Teacher training program description and objectives discussions, poster presentation, and school visits Support the development of differentiated instruction West (2016) United States Preservice teachers Secondary school Eight weeks; coteaching course by an English professor and a SE teacher Develop skills for teaching SE students and for working effectively together with specialists in public school contexts Whiteker (2018) United States Preservice teachers Primary and Secondary school Two years; master’s curriculum with emphasis on diversity and inclusion, e.g., course on culturally responsive teaching methods with emphasis on student-generated problem-based learning methods and differentiated instruction Prepare teachers to work with diverse learners Beltramo (2017) United States In-service teachers Secondary school Guided dialogues between teachers and students Construct and leverage new knowledge about students and subsequently enact more adaptive teaching practices Blik et al. (2015) Netherlands In-service teachers Vocational school Sixteen weeks; instruction, sample lessons on video, role play, own lesson recording (video), instructional coaching, coaching and selfassessment Change teacher behavior from prescriptive to interactive instruction Bower (2012) Australia In-service teachers Secondary school Eight weeks; three workshops and a mentoring session Improve the ability to differentiate the curriculum with the use of webtools and SRS’s Brigandi (2019) United States In-service teachers Primary school Six months; 2-h wholegroup sessions, workshops, and practice to increase cross-curricular strategies Develop attitudes toward and knowledge and skills regarding gifted education de Graaf (2019) Netherlands In-service teachers Secondary school One year; five 3-h sessions, lesson design cycles with increased complexity Support the redesign of lessons according to DI while matching work context, within a limited amount of time and with limited resources Mellom (2018) United States In-service teachers Primary school Two years; one week-long IC training (instructional conversation), teacher-led communication between small groups of students, and coaching support throughout one practice year Meet the needs of language learners and other Table 3 (continued ) Study Geographical setting Target group Teacher training program description and objectives culturally and linguistically diverse students Nazzal (2011) United States In-service teachers Secondary school One year; PST course for mastery DI students Implementation of DI strategies ¨Oztürk (2019) Turkey In-service teachers Preschool, primary school, secondary school one year; one shot workshops and supported 50-h in-service training Address the educational needs of all students including the disadvantaged such as disabled and SEN students Prast (2018) Netherlands In-service teachers Secondary school One year; cyclical learning pathway, 10 x 3 h instruction for strategies Develop a better response to the educational needs of students and, thus, improve student performance Schipper (2020) Netherlands In-service teachers Secondary school One year; a learning pathway consisting of two learning cycles Acquire knowledge about and insight into (the learning of) students and improve the quality of didactical decisions and lesson design Sharp (2018) Australia In-service teachers Secondary school Whole school professional learning approach targeted at heads of faculty and whole of the staff Change understandings, attitudes and practices related to differentiated instruction Smets and Struyven (2020) Belgium In-service teachers Secondary school Action research: Instruction, implementation in practice, collaborative practice and expert coaching Scaffold and support implementation of DI Valiandes (2017) Cyprus In-service teachers Secondary school Two years, subject-oriented training sessions and workshops, active reflective practice, continuous support channels and structured collaboration Improve confidence and ability to design and apply differentiated instruction Yuen (2018) Hong Kong In-service teachers Primary school Three-hour lectures, guest speakers, interactive workshops, active practice, feedback Enhance professional knowledge and confidence of teachers in adopting differentiation strategies, plan and deliver lessons for gifted students Bersh (2018) United States In-service teachers Preservice teachers Six weeks; autobiography writing, and guided reflective interview Provide insight into how own experiences are intertwined with own teacher identity and beliefs and how this shapes (future) teachership B.N.

Langelaan et al. 7manifests, for example, Dack (2018) and Smets et al. (2020). Two (quasi)-experimental studies were included (Prast et al., 2018; Schipper et al., 2020) and five studies used a preand posttest design without a control group to evaluate the programs (Blik et al., 2015; Nazzal, 2011; Valiandes & Neophytou, 2017; Wan, 2015; West & West, 2016). Eleven studies focused on program success in terms of (often qualitative) program evaluation.

3.1. Program components

The identified components of the programs in the studies from the research sample are described in this section (see Table 4) and categories are discussed in terms of frequency of occurrence. In Table 2 a brief description of (sub)categories of program components has been provided. It should be noted that active learning was the most comprehensive category with four subcategories. Active learning The data indicate that active learning is considered important for DI learning, as it had a presence in as many as 25 programs (see Table 4). In our analysis, a distinction was made between practice in design (found 19 times), simulated-based learning (6), practice in the classroom (18) and classroom inquiry (7).

Preservice teachers developed differentiated lesson plans with modified instruction based on readiness, interest, or learning profile (Dack, 2018). The intended instructional innovation can be further clarified and concretized for teachers by means of practice in simulation. Blik et al. (2015) mentioned teachers who prepared short lessons for their colleagues and acted them out as a role play. Practice in the classroom was a common characteristic in several programs, for example, teachers redesigning biology lessons in three successive cycles (de Graaf et al., 2019). In preservice programs, teacher internships were often used to practice DI in the classroom. The teacher program Teachers’ Professional Development Program for DI (PDD) aimed to develop teacher confidence and ability in designing and applying DI by designing lesson plans and implementing them in the classroom (Valiandes & Neophytou, 2017).

Practice in simulation was most frequently found in programs targeted at changing teacher attitudes, for example, simulation games for exploring cultural frames of reference (Acquah & Szelei, 2020). Nine programs made use of forms of inquiry. These programs present cyclical/research cycles, problem-based learning (PBL) or professional learning communities. Schipper et al. (2020) evaluated a cyclical adaptive teaching program with teachers who collaboratively identified a research focus, studied the curriculum, designed a lesson, taught the lesson, and observed, and evaluated in a team. PBL was used as a basis for systematic and investigative learning through small, collaborative teacher groups on messy, open-ended problems concerning DI (Goodnough, 2010).

Feedback and reflection Twenty-two programs have utilized reflective exercise and feedback, for example, by offering guided reflection questions to teachers concerning their teaching approach (LaBelle & Belknap, 2016) or through writing an autobiographical narrative to elicit teachers’ views on and choices regarding teaching (Assaf & L´opez, 2015). Reflection was the most frequently found characteristic in programs that aimed at developing teacher attitudes. This applied both to studies in which attitudes was trained among other competencies and to studies that exclusively targeted attitudinal change. Assaf and L´opez (2015) described how teachers shared learning and insights on the walls, with visual representations, quotes, and explanations.

Feedback (17) was also frequently encountered in the sample studies. The use of feedback was most frequently found in studies focusing on skill development (12). Collaboration Fostered teacher collaboration was found in 19 Table 4 Program components and outcomes. Study Content focus Active learning Collaboration Models Modeling Coaching Expert Feedback Reflection Outcomes IS SL PD PS PC IQ CP CS CM MI CA EX RF FB K S A SP Acquah (2020) x x x x x x x x + + Assaf (2015) x x x x x + Dack (2018; 2019) x x x x x x +/ + Duquette (2016) x x x x x x + Goodnough (2010) x x x x x x x x + + Kuehl (2018) x x x x x x + LaBelle (2016) x + Seglem (2015) x x x x x x x x + Wan (2015) x x x x + West (2016) x x x + Whiteker (2018) x x x x x + Beltramo (2017) x x x x + + Blik (2015) x x x x x x x x x x + Bower (2012) x x x x x x + + + Brigandi (2019) x x x x x + +/ + de Graaf (2019) x x x x x x x x x + IS SL PD PS PC IQ CP CS CM MI CA EX RF FB K S A SP Mellom (2018) x x x x x +/ Nazzal (2011) x +/ ¨Oztürk (2019) x x x x x x x +/ + Prast (2018) x x x x x x x +/ +/ Schipper (2020) x x x x x x x x x +/ + Sharp (2018) x x x x x x x x x + +/ + Smets (2020) x x x x x x x +/ Smets (2020) x x x x x x x +/ Valiandes (2017) x x x x x x x x x x + + + Yuen (2018) x x x x x x + + Bersh (2018) x + 10 7 18 6 18 9 17 5 13 11 8 7 16 15 IS SL PD PS PC IQ CP CS CM MI CA EX RF FB K S A SP Note.

If there has been positive growth, improvement, or change following a teacher program, the outcomes are categorized with a "+". If there has been partial growth, improvement, or change after a program, the outcomes are categorized with "+/ ". For example, there are sub-competencies that show growth, and sub-competencies that do not show growth. If no growth or negative growth has been measured after a program, the outcomes are categorized with ‘-’. B.N. Langelaan et al. 8programs and was further categorized into collaboration with peers and collaboration with students. Collaboration with colleagues was found most often in programs targeted at developing DI skills (16 out of 22). The program reported by Valiandes and Neophytou (2017) was aimed at promoting structured collaboration between teachers in the program on the premise that teacher-learning communities enhance teacher DI practice.

Collaboration with students was also often found in programs focused on attitudinal change (12 out of 20). Kuehl (2018) discussed a PBL-based program that supported collaborative learning to critically examine and reflect on teacher beliefs related to learning and diverse learners in the regular classroom. Four studies described collaborative structures between teachers and students. Kuehl (2018) details a preservice teacher project in which teachers and marginalized students worked together. They read the same novel and engaged in a discussion via an online dialogue journal to create teacher awareness of the need to approach individual students differently and create more understanding of how to guide them accordingly.

Content focus This category was present in 17 teacher programs and included a connection of teacher learning to teachers’ daily issues (11) and a focus on student learning (6). Program components within this category were comparatively most frequently found in programs that focus on DI skill development (12). De Graaf et al. (2019) report, for example, on a program in which teachers’ issues and personal interests were met. The project reported by Seglem and Garcia (2015) was aimed at providing teachers with the opportunity to learn more about how to navigate the language of their students’ cultures, assess their students’ needs and improve their students’ language use and communication. Models and modeling The use of models and modeling was evident in 16 programs and was divided into curricular models and modeling of instruction (see Table 4).

Curricular models were found in 14 programs, for example, the use of best practices of DI lesson design or examples of differentiated student assessment. Modeling of instruction was found in 11 programs. Goodnough (2010) recounted group sessions watching a video of a teachers effectively practicing DI. Acquah and Szelei (2020) mentioned teacher educators modeling instructions by employing activities and strategies that preservice teachers can use in their own future work, such as line-up games, group discussions and structured field experiences. Programs that aimed to enhance DI knowledge all made use of some form of modeling. Coaching and expert support In 13 of the programs, various forms of coaching and expert instruction were encountered.

Seven evaluated programs made use of experts. Brigandi et al. (2019) mentioned an educational researcher that provided whole group sessions about gifted education for teachers. Some programs provided classroom support through coaching on the job, such as an individual mentoring session that supported teachers who felt the need for more individualized support (Blik et al., 2015). A large proportion of the programs (19) had a duration of three months to one year, and six studies reported learning trajectories that took over a year. Sometimes the actual training phase was cut into two or more parts with an internship or practice in the classroom to deepen the learning experience. In-service teachers were proportionally more likely to be offered programs with longer durations than preservice teachers.

3.2. Program effectiveness

In this subsection, the reported general effects in Table 4 are related to the research designs and used measurements of the studies (see Table 5). A distinction was made between measurements of knowledge, attitude, satisfaction and skills. We present an overview of the findings related to teacher attitudes, teacher knowledge, teacher satisfaction, teacher self-reported skills, and teacher skills observed directly. Teacher attitudes Sixteen studies reported programs aimed at developing teacher attitudes toward differentiation. Fifteen (out of 16) Table 5 Overview of study design and measurements. Study Study design Data collection methods N Acquah (2020) One group, posttest Learner reports 2 Assaf (2015) One group, posttest Interviews; documents; Learner reports Dack (2018) One group, posttest Interviews; observations; documents; learner reports Dack (2019) One group, posttest Interviews; observations; documents; learner reports Dack (2020) Multiple case study Interviews; observations; documents Duquette (2016) One group, posttest Interviews; documents Goodnough (2010) One group, posttest Documents; interviews; learner reports Kuehl (2018) One group, posttest only Documents; learner reports teachers LaBelle (2016) One group, posttest only Documents 183 teachers Seglem (2015) Multiple case study Documents; learner reports teachers Wan (2015) One group only preand posttest Questionnaires; interviews; focus groups teachers West (2016) One group only preand posttest Interviews 3 teachers Whiteker (2018) Multiple case study Questionnaires; interviews; focus groups teachers Beltramo (2017) One group, posttest only Observations; interviews; documents 2 teachers Blik (2015) One group only preand posttest Observations; questionnaires; documents teachers Bower (2012) One group only preand posttest Questionnaires; documents teachers Brigandi (2019) Single case study Interviews; observations; learner reports 1 teacher de Graaf (2019) One group, posttest only Documents; questionnaires; learner reports; interviews 5 teachers Mellom (2018) Quasiexperimental preand posttest with treatment and control group Observations; documents; learner reports teachers Nazzal (2011) One group only preand posttest Observations; interviews; questionnaires 2 teachers ¨Oztürk (2019) One group, posttest only Focus groups 27 teachers Prast (2018) Quasiexperimental preand posttest Questionnaires; documents teachers (exp.) teachers (cont.) students (exp.) students (contr.) Schipper (2020) Quasiexperimental preand posttest Interviews; observations teachers (continued on next page) B.N.

Langelaan et al. 9studies showed positive outcomes in this respect. The most common characteristics of these attitude-oriented programs were reflection (10), practice in design (10), collaboration with peers (9) and the use of feedback (8). Teacher knowledge We did not find programs solely focused on knowledge development. However, in some programs knowledge development preceded skill acquisition (Brigandi et al., 2019; Dack, 2019; Sharp et al., 2018). Dack (2019) explored how the understanding of DI evolved among preservice teachers. Programs for preservice students more often emphasized, among other things, the development of knowledge about DI. All programs aimed at increasing DI knowledge report growth in this aspect.

Teacher satisfaction Three studies reported teacher satisfaction with the program. Yuen et al. (2018) found positive outcomes by measuring participants’ satisfaction with a lecture, the perceived value of the workshop and the perceived effectiveness of the trainer/facilitator. Teacher skill - self report Studies that measured the program’s success by self-assessment of DI skills (5) showed a predominantly positive picture (Bower, 2012; ¨Oztürk, 2019; Prast et al., 2018; Wan, 2015; Yuen et al., 2018). Teacher skill - direct observation or student assessment The picture is somewhat more diffuse when the success of the programs was measured by observation of teacher behavior in the classroom or student assessment, as was the case in 10 studies.

Most of the studies demonstrate skill growth, albeit with a caveat. We observed, for example, a short-term increase in skills observed, but only a partial increase in DI skills, rather than across all aspects. Some studies indicated that skills only increased in some respondents or did not indicate retention. To illustrate, Schipper et al. (2020) reported that teachers perceived various important changes in their attitudes and teaching skills, but no effects were found by means of structured observation. Prast et al. (2018) also measured the effect in terms of student performance and did not find effect. These robust studies that reported (partial) skill growth described programs primarily focused on practice in classroom (8), in design (7), teacher collaboration (6), reflection (6), coaching (6) and the use of feedback (6).

The characteristics that emerged most often in studies that showed a (partial) increase in skills development were practice in design (13), practice in the classroom (14), teacher collaboration (11), connection to teacher issues (10) and use of feedback (7). It is also noticeable that 12 of the 15 programs reporting (partial) skill development had characteristics within at least four of the main categories (see Table 2), providing a broad, comprehensive program. An example of an extensive comprehensive program can be found in the work of Prast et al. (2018). They described the application of strategies in practical exercises where teachers collaboratively prepared a mathematics lesson, with a specific focus on differentiation.

In this program, one teacher delivered the lesson while recording it on video, after which the group collectively evaluated the lesson. In addition to their active participation in team meetings, the teachers were also required to review selected literature and apply specific differentiation strategies in their mathematics lessons.

3.3. Findings regarding context

The success of the teacher programs in relation to their context was discussed in 16 of the studies (see Table 6). This section provides an overview of the contextual factors that are described in the studies as being expected to influence program success. The factors were classified as facilitators and barriers if it was reported that the contextual factor was (amply) available and positively (facilitators) or negatively (barriers) influenced the program’s effect or success. A single factor could function as either a facilitator or a barrier, depending on circumstances. As described in chapter two, the coding structure was broken down into three contextual categories: school, teacher characteristics and student characteristics (Desimone, 2009).

In this section, the factors that were most frequently identified as facilitators or barriers are discussed. Facilitators A supportive (collaborative) school culture was found in schools where structured collaboration was stimulated (Kuehl, 2018; Schipper et al., 2020; Sharp et al., 2018). The premise that changes in teacher practice require leadership support at multiple levels formed the basis of a school-wide approach as reported by Sharp et al. (2018). In this program, which was perceived positively, the school curriculum was aligned with the philosophy and practices of DI. Adequate preparation through training enhanced participants’ prior knowledge and was also identified as a facilitator for learning to differentiate instruction (Dack, 2018, 2019; Duquette & Dabrowski, 2016).

The physical learning environment is a tangible category that appeared both as barrier and as facilitator. Brigandi et al. (2019) Table 5 (continued ) Study Study design Data collection methods N (exp.) teachers (cont.) Sharp (2018) Multiple case study Questionnaires; interviews; observations; learner reports teachers Smets (2020) One group, posttest Observations; documents; interviews; focus groups teachers students Smets (2020) One group, posttest Interviews; documents teachers Valiandes (2017) One group, preand posttest Observations; interviews teachers Yuen (2018) One group, posttest Questionnaires 67 teachers Bersh (2018) Multiple case study Interviews; documents; learner reports 8 teachers Table 6 Contextual facilitators and barriers for effectiveness.

Context S T Facilitator Barriers Time x x Valiandes & Neophytou, 2017 Bower, 2012; Nazzal, 2011; ¨Oztürk, 2019; Dack, 2018; Brigandi et al., 2019. Suitable physical learning environment x Brigandi et al. (2019) Nazzal, 2011; ¨Oztürk, (Collaborative) school culture x x Kuehl, 2018 Schipper et al., 2020; Sharp et al., 2018 Dack, 2020; Nazzal, School needs and priorities x Kuehl (2018) Prast et al. (2018) School leader x x Sharp et al., 2018; Prast et al., 2018 Nazzal, 2011; Dack & Triplett, 2020 (School and national) policy Sharp et al. (2018) Dack & Triplett, 2020; Schipper et al., 2020 Nazzal (2011) Sense of urgency x x Prast et al. (2018) Prast et al. (2018) Authentic learning context x Seglem & Garcia, West et al., 2016 Teacher concerns Blik et al., 2015; Brigandi et al., 2019; de Graaf et al., 2019 Prior knowledge x Dack, 2018; Dack, 2019; Duquette, 2016 Nazzal (2011) Work experience x Prast et al., 2018; Wan, Personality traits x Brigandi et al. (2019) Brigandi et al. (2019) Note.

S = school contextual factors that relate to the school. T = contextual factors that relate to the teacher. B.N. Langelaan et al. 10mentioned that “overall, the climate in the classroom was open and accepting, complex, with varied student groupings that promoted high student mobility” (p. 381). Barriers In five of the studies the factor time was mentioned as a barrier (Bower, 2012; Brigandi et al., 2019; Dack & Triplett, 2020; Nazzal, 2011; ¨Oztürk, 2019). Some teachers indicated that they received insufficient time facilitation for the program or otherwise experienced time pressure. “I guess I’m just concerned about how much time we have in the classroom to do some of these things […] I get all the puzzle pieces, but I never have time to put the pieces together” (Brigandi et al., 2019, p. 383).

When the school’s curriculum was not in line with the principles and practice of DI, this could inhibit the DI learning process (Dack & Triplett, 2020; Nazzal, 2011; Schipper et al., 2020). For example, a school curriculum characterized by standardization and high-stakes testing compelled teachers to be less inclined to implement DI. “They were afraid that if they differentiated too often, for example differentiation of product, they wouldn’t be able to cover the curriculum before the test” (Nazzal, 2011, p. 23). Schipper et al. (2020) described how the national school curriculum employs content-focused learning objectives, which are challenging to align with the underlying principles of DI.

The absence of a supportive school learning culture created barriers to DI learning and practice, as mentioned by Dack and Triplett (2020) and Nazzal (2011). Prast et al. (2018) related the postponement of the teacher program for one year to the unexpected lack of results. “Possibly, schools in Cohort 1 were ready and motivated, whereas schools in Cohort 2 had to wait for one year during which motivation or priorities for PD may have changed” (p. 31). (Beginning) teachers with little work experience sometimes seemed overwhelmed by the vastness and multiplicity of learning the complex concept of DI (Prast et al., 2018; Wan, 2015). Finally, work experience, physical space, and personal characteristics were mentioned as barriers to learning differentiation. (Prast et al., 2018; Wan, 2015).

Nazzal (2011) and ¨Oztürk (2019) mentioned the absence of a suitable physical learning space as a barrier for DI learning. Brigandi et al. (2019) described how the personality traits of teachers continuously interact with the learning process. “Some of her personal characteristics or personality traits that get in the way (…) Perfectionism, organization, and control” (p. 383).

4. Discussion

Primary and secondary school teachers are expected to adapt their teaching to the diverse educational needs of students through DI (OECD, 2010, 2018; UNESCO, 2017). An overview of effective elements of teacher programs for DI had not yet been provided. Our literature review included 29 peer-reviewed articles, evaluating components, outcomes and contextual interplay of preservice and in-service teacher programs for DI.

4.1. Teacher programs for DI

General TPD encompasses a wide variety of forms, types, dimensions, and components. The most prevalent components in teacher programs targeted at DI we found were practice in design and classroom, teacher collaboration and reflective exercise. Teachers need to be provided with opportunities to practice DI strategies to effectively learn DI (Tomlinson & Imbeau, 2010). The assumption that DI is an integrated competence would assume that programs offering activities that coherently focus on attitudes as well as skills and knowledge are the most complete and optimal for DI learning. Therefore, teacher programs made use of practice in design and classroom to move from theory to planning and, subsequently, to implementing DI activities.

When schools offer social infrastructures that foster collaborative learning with colleagues, teachers succeed better in meeting the challenges of a diverse classroom (Fogarty & Pete, 2011; Wenger, 1998). Teachers who observe each other’s differentiated lessons, give each other feedback, and are provided time to prepare together can put into practice what they have learned. An noteworthy addition is that some programs employed structured collaboration with (future) students. Through structured collaboration with students, (preservice) teachers gained knowledge about students’ levels of achievement and knowledge of pupils’ pedagogical needs, interests, relationships, motivations, and preferred problem-solving strategies which in turn supports effective DI (Van Geel et al., 2019).

In further comparison to the broader TPD literature it is noticeable that there is significant emphasis on attitudinal development in teacher programs for DI. Attitudinal development is considered underlying and supportive for the development of DI skills (Akiba, 2011; Fives & Buehl, 2008), which was reflected in many of the studies in this review. Reflective exercise enables teachers to gain self-awareness about their practice and its impact on their students, which mediates teacher practice. When teachers reflect on and discuss their own beliefs, knowledge, attitudes, and experiences related to DI, they feel more prepared and more confident to work with diverse learners (De Neve & Devos, 2016).

4.2. Effective ingredients

The results of our analyses showed that there is not easy procedure where the following steps guarantee effectively trained DI (Frerejean et al., 2021; Suprayogi et al., 2017). We found, however, that participation in teacher programs can support improvements in knowledge about, skills for and attitudes toward DI. Program components that we discuss within this framework because they were frequently part of successful programs are practice in design and classroom, collaboration, reflection, coaching, and the use of feedback A notable difference from more general TPD is that DI is something that is ideally developed through practical exercises in the field. Real-life examples of differentiated lesson plans and teacher practice of various learning scenarios helped teachers to recognize patterns and to make better instructional decisions concerning DI.

Teacher collaboration was considered valuable and powerful and contributed to participants’ understanding of their own teaching and student learning. Reflecting on Fogarty and Pete (2011), teacher collaboration is grounded in theories that highlight the social nature of human learning and emphasize collaboration as a key to increasing teachers’ knowledge and efficacy to develop teacher practices. Collaborative approaches such as Lesson Study or participation in professional learning communities (PLCs) generate opportunities for teachers to exchange experiences within a group and engage in collective learning. Attitudinal change can be considered a prerequisite for effective DI implementation.

Some of the programs in the included studies mainly aimed at fostering a positive attitude toward student learning by critically examining teachers’ assumptions, biases and prejudice toward students. These learning approaches, most often characterized by reflective exercise, emerged as useful and relevant and showed positive outcomes. Coaching and feedback furthermore enabled teachers to gain more awareness about their practice and its impact on their students, which helped them redesign and adapt their classroom practices. In essence, an effective teacher learning program for DI is comprehensive and complete, moving from lesson design to teaching practice, where feedback and coaching help in critically assessing and enhancing one’s own practice.

Most programs reporting teacher growth incorporated several program characteristics, offering a comprehensive and well-rounded program. This makes it difficult to pinpoint which characteristics contributed to the programs’ effectiveness, but underlines the importance of overall comprehensiveness, completeness and time span. Furthermore, research outcomes without unequivocal positive effects were not considered program failures by the authors, who recognized the complexity of learning DI (Prast et al., 2018; Schipper et al., 2020; Smets et al., 2020). B.N. Langelaan et al. 114.3. Interaction with context The efficacy of a teacher program is influenced by the context in which the program is situated (De Neve & Devos, 2016; Desimone, 2009; Kerry & Kerry, 1997; VanTassel-Baska & Stambaugh, 2005).

We included the programs context to gain a better understanding of this interaction. Several contextual factors acted as facilitators and barriers. In particular, it appeared that contextual factors at the school level inhibited and facilitated teacher learning for DI. Teacher and student personality traits are difficult to control and in constant interaction with the learning process, both helping and hindering DI learning, but school-level factors are more amenable to influence and control for educators and policy makers. Time and time pressure emerged primarily as a constraining factor leading to the abandonment of activities that were not considered priorities by teachers (Valiandes & Neophytou, 2017).

This aligns with Gaikhorst (2014) and Roiha (2014) that professionalization and teacher learning should be prioritized and facilitated and should have a clear relationship with the issues teachers grapple with in their daily practice. DI is considered a complex competence which takes time and effort to effectively develop (Maulana et al., 2015). When effect and improvement are not immediately observed, teachers may abandon differentiation for other approaches perceived to be less labor-intensive quick fixes (de Graaf et al., 2019; Sherman, 2009). Novice teachers can be overwhelmed by the scope and complexity of learning DI (Wan, 2015), which calls for additional attention and support. Teachers, both consciously and unconsciously, are influenced by the requirements and standards they (think they) have to meet by the school, policies, and the curriculum. (Dack & Triplett, 2020; Schipper et al., 2020; Van Hover et al., 2011).

Whether or not DI aligns with this perceived norm impacts teachers’ willingness to implement DI in their lessons (Dack & Triplett, 2020; Schipper et al., 2020).

4.4. Limitations and further research

Some limitations are worth noting regarding the selection of the studies which cannot represent all the scholarship on this topic. Setting the time window to 2010–2020 excluded studies published before 2010 and after 2020. Selecting articles in English and Dutch excluded publications in other languages. Focusing on peer-reviewed journal articles excluded other forms of publications from the review. Research indicates that teachers improved DI practices more when a PD program was offered within a specific subject area (Kahmann et al., 2022). Subject-specific didactic approaches are excluded in this review given its focus on understanding subject-independent professionalization. The selected studies present a plethora of instruments, from selfreports to observation schemes and from perceived difficulty surveys to student assessment.

In line with Van Geel et al. (2019), and given the complexity and stratification of teacher qualities that are important for DI, the question is to what extent the diverse knowledge, skills and attitudes needed by teachers can be measured reliably and validly. Studies measuring program satisfaction showed significant results, but these outcomes do not make claims as to whether the teacher actually shows growth in DI competence. Direct observations of teacher practice did not consistently demonstrate the application of DI in real classroom settings. While we recognize the importance of supporting teachers in translating their new knowledge into classroom practice, This limitation underscores the need for a more comprehensive approach to evaluating the effectiveness of DI teacher training programs, allowing us to gain a better understanding of their efficacy.

To address this limitation in future research, it would be valuable to explore and develop more nuanced methods for assessing the integration of DI strategies in actual teaching contexts to provide a more holistic picture of the impact of teacher training programs on classroom practice.

4.5. Conclusion and implications

In our review study, all programs focused on enhancing preservice and in-service teachers knowledge, skills, and and/or attitudes for DI. The results indicate that successful DI programs incorporate active learning, collaboration and reflection. They are longitudinal, comprehensive and address attitudes, knowledge and skills. While there are examples in the literature demonstrating effective approaches, these may not always align with the realities of schools due to the time and resources they demand, as highlighted by Sims and Fletcher-Wood (2021). This assumes a precise balance between school ambition and realistic expectations for teachers, gradually building up the learning process while accepting and leaving room for the capriciousness of learning (Gaitas & Alves Martins, 2017).

When DI is regarded as a standard approach from teacher training, rather than an additional method added to the teachers’ toolbox later, this can contribute to a successful implementation in education. To secure this longitudinal learning journey, it is important to sustainably focus on developing DI competencies in both preservice teacher training and in-service programs. Preservice teachers should be confronted with their underlying beliefs and attitudinal biases from the start (Dell’Angelo & Seaton, 2016) to become familiar with DI instructional strategies. In-service teacher learning should also pay attention to teacher attitudes and must provide effective teaching methods to put DI into practice.

A facilitative (school) context is considered a prerequisite for the effectiveness of programs. In addition to a shared mutual vision, attention must be paid to supporting organizational bottlenecks. DI has been on the policy agenda in many countries for several years and is part of the supervisory framework of education inspectorates; however, there is still not a clear joint vision from all parties involved. This calls for substantive collaboration between teacher training courses, schools and, ultimately, all education professionals in the entire education chain. Learning to apply DI is a valuable and necessary part of the journey for teachers to ensure that all students receive the education to which they are entitled.

Education should draw out the potential from all students in the classroom; otherwise, it fails not only the students but also society as a whole.

Author contributions

Berber N. Langelaan: Conceptualization, Formal analysis, Investigation, Methodology, Project administration, Visualization, Writing - original draft, Writing - review & editing. Lisa Gaikhorst: Conceptualization, Methodology, Supervision, Writing - review & editing. Wouter Smets: Methodology, Supervision, Writing - review & editing. Ron J. Oostdam: Conceptualization, Project administration, Supervision, Writing - review & editing.

Declaration of competing interest

We wish to draw the attention of the Editor to the following facts which may be considered as potential conflicts of interest and to significant financial contributions to this work. We wish to confirm that there are no known conflicts of interest associated with this publication and there has been no significant financial support for this work that could have influenced its outcome. We confirm that the manuscript has been read and approved by all named authors and that there are no other persons who satisfied the criteria for authorship but are not listed. We further confirm that the order of authors listed in the manuscript has been approved by all of us. We confirm that we have given due consideration to the protection of intellectual property associated with this work and that there are no impediments to publication, including the timing of publication, with respect to intellectual property.

In so doing we confirm that we have followed the regulations of our institutions concerning intellectual property. B.N. Langelaan et al. 12We understand that the Corresponding Author is the sole contact for the Editorial process (including Editorial Manager and direct communications with the office). He/she is responsible for communicating with the other authors about progress, submissions of revisions and final approval of proofs. We confirm that we have provided a current, correct email address which is accessible by the Corresponding Author.

Data availability

No data was used for the research described in the article.

References

  1. 1Acquah (2020). The potential of modelling culturally responsive teaching: Pre-service teachers' learning experiences. Teaching in Higher Education, 25, 157. https://doi.org/10.1080/13562517.2018.1547275
  2. 2Akiba (2011). Identifying program characteristics for preparing pre-service teachers for diversity. Teachers College Record, 113, 658. https://doi.org/10.1177/016146811111300304
  3. 3Assaf (2015). Generative learning in a service-learning project and field-base teacher education program: Learning to become culturally responsive teachers. Literacy Research: Theory, Method, and Practice, 64, 323.
  4. 4Belfi (2012). The effect of class composition by gender and ability on secondary school students' school well-being and academic self-concept: A literature review. Educational Research Review, 7, 62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2011.09.002
  5. 5Beltramo (2017). Developing adaptive teaching practices through participation in cogenerative dialogues. Teaching and Teacher Education, 63, 326. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.01.007
  6. 6Bersh (2018). Writing autobiography to develop culturally responsive competency: Teachers' intersections of personal histories, cultural backgrounds and biases. International Journal of Educational Research, 88, 31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2018.01.007
  7. 7Blik (2015). Docenttraining Interactieve Instructie. Verandering van het lesgeven en de zelfstandige taakuitvoering van moeilijk lerenden. Pedagogische Studies, 92, 290.
  8. 8Bondie (2019). How does changing “one-size-fits-all” to differentiated instruction affect teaching?. Review of Research in Education, 43, 336. https://doi.org/10.3102/0091732X18821130
  9. 9Borko (2004). Professional Development and Teacher Learning: Mapping the Terrain. Educational Researcher, 33, 3. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X033008003
  10. 10Bower (2012). An ability approach to within-class curriculum differentiation using student response systems and web 2.0 technologies: Analysing teachers' responsiveness. Themes in Science and Technology Education, 5, 5.
  11. 11Brevik (2018). Student teachers' practice and experience with differentiated instruction for students with higher learning potential. Teaching and Teacher Education, 71, 34. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.12.003
  12. 12Brigandi (2019). Professional development and differentiated instruction in an elementary school pullout program: A gifted education case study. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 42, 362. https://doi.org/10.1177/0162353219874418
  13. 13Dack (2018). Structuring teacher candidate learning about differentiated instruction through coursework. Teaching and Teacher Education, 69, 62. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.09.017
  14. 14Dack (2019). Understanding teacher candidate misconceptions and concerns about differentiated instruction. The Teacher Educator, 54, 22. https://doi.org/10.1080/08878730.2018.1485802
  15. 15Dack (2020). Novice social studies teachers' implementation of differentiation: A longitudinal multicase study. Theory & Research in Social Education, 48, 32. https://doi.org/10.1080/00933104.2019.1640149
  16. 16Darling-Hammond (2017).
  17. 17De Graaf (2019). A practical approach to differentiated instruction: How biology teachers redesigned their genetics and ecology lessons. Journal of Science Teacher Education, 30, 6. https://doi.org/10.1080/1046560X.2018.1523646
  18. 18De Neve (2016). The role of environmental factors in beginning teachers' professional learning related to differentiated instruction. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 27, 357. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2015.1122637
  19. 19Dee (2010). Preservice teacher application of differentiated instruction. The Teacher Educator, 46, 53. https://doi.org/10.1080/08878730.2010.529987
  20. 20Dell'Angelo (2016). Students and teachers Co-constructing identity. Journal of Urban Learning, Teaching, and Research, 12, 124.
  21. 21Denessen (2017). Verantwoord omgaan met verschillen: Sociaal-culturele achtergronden en differentiatie in het Onderwijs [Dealing responsibly with differences: Socio-cultural backgrounds and differentiation in education.
  22. 22Desimone (2009). Improving impact studies of teachers' professional development: Toward better conceptualizations and measures. Educational Researcher, 38, 181. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X08331140
  23. 23Deunk (2018). Effective differentiation practices: A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies on the cognitive effects of differentiation practices in primary education. Educational Research Review, 24, 31. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2018.02.002
  24. 24D'Intino (2021). Differentiated instruction: A review of teacher education practices for Canadian pre-service elementary school teachers. Journal of Education for Teaching, 47, 668. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607476.2021.1951603
  25. 25Dixon (2014). Differentiated instruction, professional development, and teacher efficacy. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 37, 111. https://doi.org/10.1177/0162353214529042
  26. 26Duquette (2016). A study of classroom inquiry and reflection among preservice teachers candidates. McGill Journal of Education/Revue des sciences de l'éducation de McGill, 51, 575. https://doi.org/10.7202/1037360ar
  27. 27Dweck (2015). Growth [editorial]. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 85, 242. https://doi.org/10.1111/bjep.12072
  28. 28Eysink (2017). Supporting primary school teachers in differentiating in the regular classroom. Teaching and Teacher Education, 66, 107. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.04.002
  29. 29Feiman-Nemser (2001). From preparation to practice: Designing a continuum to strengthen and sustain teaching. Teachers College Record, 103, 1013. https://doi.org/10.1111/0161-4681.00141
  30. 30Fives (2008). What do teachers believe? Developing a framework for examining beliefs about teachers' knowledge and ability. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 33, 134. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2008.01.001
  31. 31Fogarty (2011).
  32. 32Frerejean (2021). Ten steps to 4C/ID: Training differentiation skills in a professional development program for teachers. Instructional Science, 49, 395. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11251-021-09540-x
  33. 33Gaikhorst (2014).
  34. 34Gaitas (2017). Teacher perceived difficulty in implementing differentiated instructional strategies in primary school. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 21, 544. https://doi.org/10.1080/13603116.2016.1223180
  35. 35Gay (2010). Acting on beliefs in teacher education for cultural diversity. Journal of Teacher Education, 61, 143. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487109347320
  36. 36Gay (2018).
  37. 37Gheyssens (2020). Good things come to those who wait: The importance of professional development for the implementation of differentiated instruction. Frontiers in Education, 96, 1.
  38. 38Goodnough (2010). Investigating pre-service science teachers' developing professional knowledge through the lens of differentiated instruction. Research in Science Education, 40, 239. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-009-9120-6
  39. 39Graham (2021). A scoping review of 20 years of research on differentiation : Investigating conceptualisation , characteristics , and methods used. The Review of Education, 9, 161. https://doi.org/10.1002/rev3.3238
  40. 40Griful-Freixenet (2020). Connecting beliefs, noticing and differentiated teaching practices: A study among pre-service teachers and teachers. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 1.
  41. 41Guskey (2002). Professional development and teacher change. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 8, 381. https://doi.org/10.1080/135406002100000512
  42. 42Guskey (2003). What makes professional development effective?. Phi Delta Kappan, 84, 748. https://doi.org/10.1177/003172170308401007
  43. 43Jager (2022). Capturing instructional differentiation in educational research: Investigating opportunities and challenges. Educational Research, 64, 1. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131881.2022.2063751
  44. 44Kahmann (2022). Meta-analysis of professional development programs in differentiated instruction. International Journal of Educational Research, 116, 1. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijer.2022.102072
  45. 45Kerry (1997). Differentiation: Teachers' views of the usefulness of recommended strategies in helping the more able pupils in primary and secondary classrooms. Educational Studies, 23, 439. https://doi.org/10.1080/0305569970230309
  46. 46Keuning (2017). Differentiëren bij rekenen: Een cognitieve taakanalyse van het denken en handelen van basisschoolleerkrachten. Pedagogische studiën, 94, 160.
  47. 47Kitchenham (2007). Guidelines for performing systematic literature reviews in software engineering.
  48. 48Korthagen (2004). In search of the essence of a good teacher: Towards a more holistic approach in teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 20, 77. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2003.10.002
  49. 49Kuehl (2018). Using professional learning communities to advance preservice teachers' understanding of differentiation within writing instruction. Teacher Educators' Journal, 11, 70.
  50. 50LaBelle (2016). Reflective journaling: Fostering dispositional development in preservice teachers. Reflective Practice, 17, 125. https://doi.org/10.1080/14623943.2015.1134473
  51. 51Matsko (2014). Unpacking the “urban” in urban teacher education: Making a case for context-specific preparation. Journal of Teacher Education, 65, 128. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487113511645
  52. 52Matsko (2022).
  53. 53Maulana (2015). Development and evaluation of a questionnaire measuring pre-service teachers' teaching behaviour: A rasch modelling approach. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 26, 169. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2014.939198
  54. 54Mellom (2018). “They come with nothing:” How professional development in a culturally responsive pedagogy shapes teacher attitudes towards Latino/a English language learners. Teaching and Teacher Education, 71, 98. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.12.013
  55. 55Miles (2014).
  56. 56Moher (2009). Preferred reporting Items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement. PLoS Medicine, 6. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1000097
  57. 57Nazzal (2011). Differentiation in practice: An exploration of first year teacher implementation of differentiation strategies as expected outcomes of teacher preparation program. Current issues in middle level education, 16, 17.
  58. 58(2010).
  59. 59(2018).
  60. 60Öztürk (2019). An evaluation of an innovative in-service teacher training model in Turkey. International Journal of Higher Education, 8, 23. https://doi.org/10.5430/ijhe.v8n1p23
  61. 61Parsons (2018). Teachers' instructional adaptations: A research synthesis. Review of Educational Research, 88, 205. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654317743198
  62. 62Pozas (2020). Teachers and differentiated instruction: Exploring differentiation practices to address student diversity. Journal of Research in Special Educational Needs, 20, 217. https://doi.org/10.1111/1471-3802.12481
  63. 63Prast (2018). Differentiated instruction in primary mathematics: Effects of teacher professional development on student achievement. Learning and Instruction, 54, 22. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2018.01.009
  64. 64Prast (2015). Readiness-based differentiation in primary school mathematics: Expert recommendations and teacher self-assessment. Frontline Learning Research, 3, 90.
  65. 65Roiha (2014). Teachers' views on differentiation in content and language integrated learning (CLIL): Perceptions, practices and challenges. Language and Education, 28, 1. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500782.2012.748061
  66. 66Rubie-Davies (2010). Teacher expectations and perceptions of student attributes: Is there a relationship?. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 80, 121. https://doi.org/10.1348/000709909X466334
  67. 67Ruys (2012). Differentiated instruction in teacher education: A case study of congruent teaching. Teachers and Teaching, 19, 93. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2013.744201
  68. 68Scarparolo (2021). A systematic review of pre-service teachers ’ self- efficacy beliefs for differentiated instruction. Teachers and Teaching, 27, 753. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2021.2007371
  69. 69Schipper (2020). Becoming a more adaptive teacher through collaborating in lesson study? Examining the influence of lesson study on teachers' adaptive teaching practices in mainstream secondary education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 88, 109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2019.102961
  70. 70Seglem (2015). “So we have to teach them or what?”: Introducing preservice teachers to the figured worlds of urban youth through digital conversation. Teachers College Record, 117, 1. https://doi.org/10.1177/016146811511700301
  71. 71Sharp (2018). Leadership for differentiated instruction: Teachers' engagement with on-site professional learning at an Australian secondary school. International Journal of Inclusive Education, 24, 901. https://doi.org/10.1080/13603116.2018.1492639
  72. 72Sherman (2009). Haven't we seen this before? Sustaining a vision in teacher education for progressive teaching practice. Teacher Education Quarterly, 36, 41.
  73. 73Sims (2021). Identifying the characteristics of effective teacher professional development: A critical review. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 32, 47. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2020.1772841
  74. 74Smale-Jacobse (2019). Differentiated instruction in secondary education: A systematic review of research evidence. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, 1. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpsyg.2019.02366
  75. 75Smets (2019). Implementing differentiated instruction in secondary education: The nexus between theory and practice.
  76. 76Smets (2020). Responding to students' learning needs: How secondary education teachers learn to implement differentiated instruction. Educational Action Research, 30, 243. https://doi.org/10.1080/09650792.2020.1848604
  77. 77Smets (2018). Aligning with complexity: System-theoretical principles for research on differentiated instruction. Frontline Learning Research, 6, 66. https://doi.org/10.14786/flr.v6i2.340
  78. 78Smets (2020). A teachers' professional development programme to implement differentiated instruction in secondary education: How far do teachers reach?. Cogent Education, 7. https://doi.org/10.1080/2331186X.2020.1742273
  79. 79Specht (2016).
  80. 80Steenbergen-Hu (2016). What one hundred years of research says about the effects of ability grouping and acceleration on K–12 students' academic achievement: Findings of two second-order meta-analyses. Review of Educational Research, 86, 849. https://doi.org/10.3102/0034654316675417
  81. 81Stradling (1993). Differentiation in practice: Responding to the needs of all pupils. Educational Research, 35, 127. https://doi.org/10.1080/0013188930350202
  82. 82Suprayogi (2017). Teachers and their implementation of differentiated instruction in the classroom. Teaching and Teacher Education, 67, 291. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2017.06.020
  83. 83Tomlinson (2014).
  84. 84Tomlinson (2003). Differentiating instruction in response to student readiness, interest, and learning profile in academically diverse classrooms: A review of literature. Journal for the Education of the Gifted, 27, 119. https://doi.org/10.1177/016235320302700203
  85. 85Tomlinson (2010).
  86. 86(2017).
  87. 87Valiandes (2017). Teachers' professional development for differentiated instruction in mixed-ability classrooms: Investigating the impact of a development program on teachers' professional learning and on students' achievement. Teacher Development, 22, 123. https://doi.org/10.1080/13664530.2017.1338196
  88. 88Van Geel (2019). Capturing the complexity of differentiated instruction. School Effectiveness and School Improvement, 30, 51. https://doi.org/10.1080/09243453.2018.1539013
  89. 89Van Geel (2022). How teachers develop skills for implementing differentiated instruction: Helpful and hindering factors. Teaching and Teacher Education: Leadership and Professional Development, 1, 1.
  90. 90Van Hover (2011). Multiple paths to testable content? Differentiation in a high-stakes testing context. Social Studies Research & Practice, 6, 34. https://doi.org/10.1108/SSRP-03-2011-B0003
  91. 91Van Veen (2012). What makes teacher professional development effective? A literature review.
  92. 92VanTassel-Baska (2005). Challenges and possibilities for serving gifted learners in the regular classroom. Theory Into Practice, 44, 211. https://doi.org/10.1207/s15430421tip4403_5
  93. 93Wan (2015). Differentiated instruction: Hong Kong prospective teachers' teaching efficacy and beliefs. Teachers and Teaching, 22, 148. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2015.1055435
  94. 94Wenger (1998). Communities of practice: Learning as a social system. Systems thinker, 1.
  95. 95Wertheim (2002). Efficacy beliefs, background variables, and differentiated instruction of Israeli prospective teachers. The Journal of Educational Research, 96, 54. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220670209598791
  96. 96West (2016). Integrating differentiation in English education methods courses: Learning from the perceptions and experiences of teacher candidates. The Teacher Educator, 51, 115. https://doi.org/10.1080/08878730.2016.1151091
  97. 97Whitaker (2018). Enhancing preservice teachers' motivation to teach diverse learners. Teaching and Teacher Education, 73, 171. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2018.04.004
  98. 98Wilkinson (2014). The effects of setting on classroom teaching and student learning in mainstream mathematics, English and science lessons: A critical review of the literature in ngland. Educational Review, 66, 411. https://doi.org/10.1080/00131911.2013.787971
  99. 99Xiao (2019). Guidance on conducting a systematic literature review. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 39, 93. https://doi.org/10.1177/0739456X17723971
  100. 100Yuen (2018). Differentiation in key learning areas for gifted students in regular classes: A project for primary school teachers in Hong Kong. Gifted Education International, 34, 36. https://doi.org/10.1177/0261429416649047