Bibliographic record of an article published in Teaching and Teacher Education (Elsevier), Volume 144, article 104599. It is not a publication of this journal. Metadata retrieved from Crossref and OpenAlex (2026-11-17).
Abstract and full text reproduced from the published version under CC BY 4.0. © The authors.
Read the article on the publisher’s site ↗The role of research experiences in developing pre-service teachers’ epistemic beliefs
Show affiliations and correspondence
- aUniversity of Limerick; University of Oxford
- bUniversity of Limerick
- cUniversity of Oxford
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2024.104599
Outline
Abstract
Persistent concerns about the theory-practice gap and desires for an ‘evidence-informed’ teaching profession have prompted research into how teachers' epistemic beliefs influence their acceptance or rejection of educational research. This study analyses longitudinal interview data from six pre-service teachers (PSTs) to explore how experiences of conducting research (in the domains of science or education) during initial teacher education (ITE) contribute to epistemological development. These research experiences provided opportunities for ad-hoc epistemological development, even in the absence of intentional efforts. Epistemic beliefs sometimes appeared to be supplanted, counterproductively, from science to education. The implications for teacher education and research are discussed.
1. Introduction
There have been many arguments in recent times within international research literature and policy to support the teaching profession becoming more evidence-informed and research-engaged (e.g., BERA-RSA, 2014; O′ Donoghue et al., 2017; Tripney, Gough, Sharples, Lester, & Bristow, 2018). Such trends come in the context of decades of research about the persistence of a theory-practice or research-practice ‘gap’ in education (Korthagen & Kessels, 1999; McGarr et al., 2017), often related to negative perceptions of educational theory and research. In advancing the ‘research-informed teaching’ or ‘teacher-as-researcher’ agendas, many initial teacher education (ITE) providers have sought to include research projects in their programmes (e.g., Brew & Saunders, 2020; Kitchen & Petrarca, 2016).
Some research experiences for both pre-service and in-service teachers have been evaluated or shared through the literature (e.g., Flores, 2016; Hardoim et al., 2014; Lapostolle & Chevaillier, 2011) but it is not often that the research experiences are explicitly rationalised in teacher education literature as a mechanism for developing the individual’s beliefs about the nature of knowledge and nature of knowing. Such beliefs are known as epistemic beliefs, or sometimes personal epistemologies (Hofer & Pintrich, 1997). Epistemic beliefs are generally important because they act as filters for how individuals view information and are therefore vital in learning (Luft & Roehrig, 2007). Epistemic beliefs have been found to influence pre-service teachers’ perceptions of educational research (Joram, 2007; Preiser et al., 2022) and support or hinder teachers ‘buy-in’ to evidence-informed and research-engaged practice (Joram, et al., 2020).
It is vital that we begin to understand how learning activities within teacher education can be leveraged for epistemological development. Student-conducted research projects naturally embed many activities that have been suggested as developmental for epistemic beliefs, such as engaging with contradictory literature, understanding research methods, argumentation, and increasing subject knowledge (Gill et al., 2004; Iordanou, 2010; Walker et al., 2012; Yilmaz-Tuzun & Topcu, 2008). So, research projects in ITE have the potential to develop epistemic beliefs conducive to integrating knowledge from education research but this has yet to be systematically investigated. There are multiple forms of research experiences often already organised in ITE programmes, but we know little about how they foster epistemological development.
Our own previously published work suggests that ITE ought to focus on epistemic development of PSTs in both their subject matter discipline and Education Studies (Guilfoyle et al., 2020). The current study provides an exploration by examining pre-service teachers’ (PSTs’) experiences of research projects in ITE. It draws on a longitudinal qualitative study of science teachers’ epistemological development as they move from pre-service post-primary teacher education to post-qualification employment (Guilfoyle, 2018). The study particularly focuses on the development of PSTs epistemic beliefs as they engaged in research projects during the final year of their ITE programme. Research projects were already a part of the ITE programme and could be conducted in the discipline of science or Education Studies (including science education).
In summary, this paper aims to explore how student research projects in ITE can promote epistemological development. To understand the * Corresponding author. 15 Norham Gardens, Oxford, OX2 6PY, UK. 2relevance of this exploration and contextualize the work, this introduction has outlined some key points which will be expanded further in subsequent sections: (1) there is a desire to make the teaching profession more evidence-informed and research engaged, (2) epistemic beliefs play an important role in teachers’ perceptions of educational research, and (3) while some ITE courses include research experiences, they often do not explicitly aim to develop epistemic beliefs. This paper will address this question ‘How do different research experiences in ITE (in the domains of science and Education Studies) contribute to the development of PSTs’ epistemic beliefs that are conducive for their buy-in to educational research?’ By identifying potential opportunities and barriers for epistemic belief development in existing ITE practices, this knowledge can inform future research and practice of teacher education.
1.1. Epistemic beliefs and epistemological development in teacher
education Individuals’ epistemic beliefs, sometimes also known as personal epistemologies, are vitally important to the process of learning generally (Mason, 2010; Muis, 2007) and learning to teach in particular (Buehl & Fives, 2016; Fives, 2011). With a growing body of evidence, scholars argue that ‘it is clear that teacher education programmes must concentrate on the determination and development of PSTs’ epistemological beliefs’ (Yilmaz-Tuzun & Topcu, 2008, p. 82). In this section, we briefly review how epistemic beliefs have been addressed in relation to the domains of science and Education Studies, before highlighting the dearth of research on the interaction between the beliefs in these two domains.
In doing so, we argue the importance of epistemic beliefs and epistemological development in teacher education. It has long been argued that it is essential for teachers, and ultimately students, to learn not just the substantive content knowledge of their disciplines but also the syntactic knowledge of the discipline, that is how these disciplines operate procedurally and epistemically (Schwab, 1962; Ball & McDiarmid, 1990). This agenda has been pursued in several different ways in different disciplines. In science education, for example, there have been at least two strong lines of research with this agenda (Elby et al., 2016). One of these lines of research has been in advocating for students’ understanding of the Nature of Science (NOS) which typically refers to the epistemology of science (Lederman, 2007) or, at least, the epistemology and epistemic practices of science are positioned as part of a wider conceptualisation of NOS (Erduran & Dagher, 2014).
The second line of research has been in the application of personal epistemology, and related constructs from psychology to science education. In a review of 37 papers in this line of research, Yang and Tsai (2012) found that personal epistemology had been shown to effect science learning across the cognitive, psychomotor, and affective domains. Teachers’ epistemic beliefs in the domain of ‘Education Studies’ has been the focus of far less research. This, in part, may be due to the extent to which this domain is so contextually variable. In a volume edited by Whitty and Furlong (2017) contributors from various countries articulate how educational knowledge and the traditions of educational research are exceptionally different, nuanced by the particular history and features of their contexts.
This means that drawing the boundaries of the discipline, (see Furlong, 2013 for discussion of Education Studies as a discipline) is remarkably difficult. However, some studies have nevertheless sought to understand teachers’ epistemic beliefs about educational research and the implications of these beliefs. For example, Joram (2007) found that the epistemic beliefs of pre-service teachers, practicing teachers, and teacher education professors about education research differed in ways that appeared to have implications for their acceptance or rejection of the validity of such research. In this case, that PSTs believed educational knowledge was highly particularistic and not falsifiable. Similarly, Bondy et al. (2007) demonstrate, through the use of particularly illustrative cases, how epistemic beliefs of pre-service teachers mediate their engagement with knowledge in their teacher education.
Later work by Joram et al. (2020) found that epistemic beliefs, particularly about generalizability/transferability, and the need for certainty, were important factors in teacher ‘buy-in’ to use educational research. Merk et al. (2017) also found epistemic beliefs about what they term ‘general pedagogical knowledge’ may play a role in pre-service teachers’ devaluation of such knowledge. One major challenge in teacher education is that teachers are expected to navigate knowledge both their subject discipline and the field of Education Studies or educational research simultaneously. This means they must grapple with knowledge rooted in quite different epistemologies (e.g., the theories in education are quite different to those in science).
While the struggle for teachers to engage with educational research has been studied extensively for many years (Korthagen & Kessels, 1999; McGarr et al., 2017), only recently have teacher educators begun to recognise the impact of teachers’ beliefs about their subject discipline on how they perceive other professional knowledgebases such as educational theory and research (L¨ofstr¨om & Pursiainen, 2015). For example, the study reported in Guilfoyle et al. (2020) illuminated how PSTs appeared to reject knowledge from Education Studies both when it was believed to be extremely epistemically different to science (e.g., less robust therefore not trustworthy) and when it was believed to be extremely epistemically similar (e.g., producing universal knowledge claims that are not perceived as useful when classrooms are so context-specific).
In that study, PSTs with a more nuanced understanding of epistemic comparisons between the domains appeared to show critical engagement with educational research for practice. This navigation between disciplines is complicated by tensions of identity, for example, between seeing oneself as a teacher or disciplinary expert such as a scientist, historian, mathematician, etc. (Jorde & Tellefsen, 2017), and by the finding that one’s multiple identities may result in what Gottlieb and Wineburg (2012) term ‘epistemic switching’, where different epistemic standards are applied depending on the aspect of one’s identity that is invoked in a given context. Given the emerging importance of epistemic beliefs in learning to teach, teacher educators may wish to put particular effort into supporting epistemological development during teacher education.
There are many ways in which epistemic beliefs might be developed in teacher education. For example, Walker et al. (2012) suggested that teaching experience on school placement, increasing subject knowledge, engaging in reflective practice, and encountering contradictions in theory or opinion in their ITE programme may all ‘play a role’ in epistemological development. In this paper, we consider the role of research experiences in epistemological development.
1.2. Research experience in initial teacher education
Many ITE programmes include research experiences as part of the curriculum, but with a wide variety of intentions and forms of implementation (Flores, 2016). Across the globe, teacher educators are recognising that quality teacher education programmes involve some element of research experience (Darling-Hammond, 2006, 2010). The presence of research experiences in Finnish teacher education is considered to be a key component of their successful educational outcomes at school level (H¨okk¨a & Etel¨apelto, 2013; Sahlberg, 2011) and research experiences are considered to be strongly valued components of teacher education in France (Lapostolle & Chevaillier, 2011), Portugal (Flores, 2016), and Brazil (Hardoim et al., 2014).
In many cases, pre-service teachers are found to value the research experiences which they feel promote their development towards evidence-informed practice (Niemi & Nevgi, 2014; Sozbilir, 2007). Other benefits of research, and rationales for its inclusion, include: greater coherence and knowledge integration in the teacher education curriculum (Conway et al., 2009), making apparent the links between theory and practice (Flores, 2016), developing professionals capable of researching their own practice to improve teaching (Medwell & Wray, 2014), and enhancing skills in reading and interpretation of research for practice (Healey & Jenkins, 2009). It is worth noting these experiences L. Guilfoyle et al. 3are of educational research, or within the cognate disciplines of ‘Education Studies’, rather than research in subject disciplines such as science, history, or math (BERA-RSA, 2014).
On other hand, authentic research experiences within the discipline of the pre-service teachers’ content area (e.g., science) are thought to be important for developing disciplinary literacies and understanding of the nature of science (Brown & Melear, 2007; Schwartz et al., 2004). Krim et al. (2019) reviewed 307 papers in the STEM education field that reported on students’ engagement in research experiences in undergraduate degree programmes, and with in-service teachers. These are research experiences located in subject disciplines. Even the teaching-orientated projects, referred to as Teacher Research Experiences (TREs), are focused on the subject area where the ‘outcomes of these experiences include increased STEM knowledge and experience, scientific research practices, career awareness, and STEM self-efficacy and identity’ (Krim et al., 2019, p. 3).
These subject-specific experiences appear to receive little-to-no attention in the more domain-general teacher education literature (Loughran & Hamilton, 2016), where the research projects discussed are instead educational in focus (Tatto & Furlong, 2015). So it appears while much work has been done to consider the role of research in both science education and teacher education literature bases, there is a disconnect in their foci that perhaps mirrors the tension between the knowledgebases of educational and scientific research that PSTs and in-service teachers are expected to navigate unsupported. Furthermore, while research experiences in science are rationalised by an increased understanding of the epistemic nature of science as an outcome, very rarely are the inclusion of research experiences in teacher education literature explicitly rationalised on the basis of the opportunity for epistemological development or epistemic comparison between one’s subject area and educational research.
The empirical study presented in the paper sought to understand how such research projects, as they are currently embedded in a teacher education programme, might have potential for epistemological development, where such development is considered important for supporting an evidence-informed profession. Therefore, the research question that this paper will address is ‘How do different research experiences in ITE (in the domains of science and Education Studies) contribute to the development of PSTs’ epistemic beliefs that are conducive for their buyin to educational research?’
1.3. Conceptualisation of epistemic beliefs
The theoretical model of epistemic beliefs used in this study draws primarily on the work of Hofer and Pintrich (1997), though with cognisance of more recent theoretical and empirical contributions (e.g. Chinn et al., 2011; Hofer, 2016). Within this model, epistemic beliefs are considered in terms of a number of ‘more or less’ independent dimensions, concerning the nature of knowledge and knowing (Hofer, 2016). These dimensions are the certainty, simplicity, and universality of knowledge, where the latter two are sub-elements of the ‘structure’ of knowledge (Chinn et al., 2011), as well as the source of knowledge and justification for knowing. Aside from the independence of each dimension to develop while others do not, it is also possible for individuals to hold different epistemic beliefs for different domains/disciplines (e.g., in science, psychology, mathematics); that is to say that they can be domain-specific (Hofer, 2000; Urhahne & Kremer, 2023).
These dimensions have long been considered as spectra running from ‘less developed’ to ‘more developed’, or from ‘naïve’ to ‘sophisticated’. These are value-laden terms which researchers generally defend as necessary when considering unior multi-dimensional epistemological development (Schommer-Aikins, 2002). However, as we note in the analysis section, we account for the complexity of these beliefs rather than simply labelling them with such value-laden dichotomous terms. While we are mindful of not imposing our values, as educators, we do acknowledge that certain beliefs, or a combination of beliefs, can be conducive or hinder students in achieving intended learning outcomes (e.g. engaging with knowledge from Education Studies).
This conceptualisation of epistemic beliefs is useful because it theoretically recognises the domain-specific nature of beliefs, while also being sufficiently general to be applied to different domains (in this case science, and Education Studies). Below is a brief expansion on each of these dimensions in turn, as described for the purposes of this study. Certainty of knowledge is concerned with the extent to which knowledge is viewed as fixed or fluid. An individual may consider knowledge to be existing with certainty. In such cases, knowledge would not be doubted, all experts would come up with the same answer to a question, and that answer would not change over time. At the other end of the spectrum, individuals would be open to the idea that theories are modified over time as more information is gathered, and that knowledge is not certain or absolute.
A nuanced position might recognise that in any domain or discipline there is some knowledge that is core, fundamental and well established, while knowledge at the fringes of discovery might be more tentative and open to revision. Structure of knowledge can include several features. See Chinn et al. (2011) for a brief elucidation of these. For the purposes of this study, we consider two: simplicity and universality of knowledge. Simplicity is concerned with beliefs about knowledge as an accumulation of facts or as highly interrelated concepts. On one side of the spectrum one might consider answers to be straightforward and knowledge to be discrete, concrete and easily knowable. On the other side, the knowledge is understood as complex and relative to other concepts.
A nuanced position is quite close to the Polar End 2, understanding knowledge as more complex and inter-related. Universality is concerned with the extent to which knowledge is universally applicable across contexts (Polar End 1), or highly context specific (Polar End 2). A nuanced middle ground position might acknowledge that knowledge can be generated in context but can be useful in other contexts – what is often called ‘transferability’ by qualitative researchers (e.g., Lincoln & Guba, 1985; Tracy, 2010) or that it might be generalised to different degrees. Justification for knowing is concerned with how individuals evaluate knowledge, how they use or evaluate evidence, authority, and expertise.
One polar end of this dimension would include belief in knowledge as justified by expert opinion alone, while the other end of the spectrum would involve a belief in knowledge justified by personal experience and intuition. A more nuanced position might acknowledge this need to rely on testimony, but balance it with a recognition of the need for evaluation of this testimony for plausibility, whether there is consensus, and how it integrates with what is already known (Bråten et al., 2011). Source of knowledge is concerned with beliefs about knowledge as residing outside the self, which is transmitted from expert/authority to the learner and should not be questioned. Individuals might, alternatively, consider knowledge as constructed in interaction with others.
An individual would move from being a spectator to being an active participant in constructing knowledge, using logic and evidence. A nuanced view might strike a balance by acknowledging that multiple sources, including personal experience, can be used to support a claim.
2. Methods
2.1. Research context
The research reported in this paper is situated in the context of a larger project that traced epistemological development of PSTs, in science and Education Studies, over an 18-month period spanning their final year of ITE and first year post-qualification. The project was undertaken in a University in the Republic of Ireland which was the largest provider of post-primary teacher education in the country (O’ Doherty, 2016). Two routes of teacher education are offered by the university: a 4-year concurrent bachelors programme and a 2-year Professional Master of Education (PME) in a range of subject areas (e.g., science, L. Guilfoyle et al. 4technology, math, languages, physical education). The curriculum of teacher education in Ireland is broadly regulated by the Teaching Council (2017; 2020), but with some local control about how to meet these requirements, subject to approval.
While programmes must consist of particular proportions of various elements (i.e., 50% subject discipline, 25% Foundation and Professional Studies, 25% school placement), developing ‘The Teacher as … Researcher’ was listed as a mandatory element of all programmes, but without specific time requirements (2017, p. 14). This paper focuses only on PSTs in the 4-year concurrent programme (i.e., where students engage in both scientific education and teacher education concurrently) who had a research project embedded into their final year of studies spread across both semesters. This was a mandatory element and amounted to about 5% of the programme (12 credits of 240). Table 2 presents extracts from the module outline for each of the two modules, indicating the syllabus and learning outcomes.
A more complete account of the curriculum of the programme is published elsewhere (Guilfoyle et al., 2020). Learning experiences, while a standard heading of the university module outline, are not stated in either case. This is perhaps indicative of the personal supervision approach that was adopted, where each student was supervised by an academic staff member in the university relevant to their project topic, rather than receiving whole-group instruction. What can be seen from this table is that while capacity for disciplinary procedures such as literature reviews, data collection, analysis, and critical discussion were all intended learning outcomes, there were no specific outcomes to develop an explicit understanding of the epistemologies of the disciplines.
These learning outcomes are broadly similar to those for FYPs from other undergraduate programmes in different subject areas both within and beyond the institution.
2.2. Participants
Six PSTs, from a cohort of 72, participated in the full longitudinal study (Saldana, 2003). These participants are referred to by pseudonyms; Bruce, Monica, Harvey, Lisa, Haley, and Lana. In their course, they could specialise in biology and chemistry or biology and physics. Only Haley was on the biology and physics route. Ethical approval was sought and granted from the institutional ethics committee where the research was conducted. Participation was entirely voluntary and self-selecting by responding to an open invitation to the whole cohort. While there were 12 participants at the beginning of the study, participants were informed of their right to withdraw at any stage, and only 6 chose to continue to participate throughout the full 18-months to provide a full data set for analysis.
All PSTs in this study conducted a research project as part of their final year of ITE. This research could be conducted in their subject area of science, or in Education Studies (which included topics specifically on science education). However, the experience of conducting research was unique for each of the participants, and their subsequent learning was quite different. It is important to note that the participants did not engage in any research methods modules but rather learned methods by engaging with a supervisor. Table 3 shows a summary brief description of the research project foci and experiences for each participant. These are intentionally vague because the individual nature of the projects would mean that even rather limited details could identify a participant.
Harvey and Lisa did their research in the biological sciences, Bruce and Monica did their research in Education Studies, and Lana’s was focused on science education. Haley also did her FYP in the biological sciences and went on to pursue further research in this area. While Haley’s engagement with further scientific research lies outside the ITE structure, some reflections on this experience are included to further illustrate the potential influence of research experiences.
2.3. Data collection
Each participant engaged in an in-depth interview at the beginning of their final year of the bachelors’ programme (Data Point 1; DP1), at the end of their final year (DP2), and one year after the programme (DP3). The key data points for this study are DP1 and DP2, as pre-post interviews for the final year research project, but DP3 data is also considered because reflections on the research project are also given here. Explicit reflections on the FYP experience are included in the DP2 interview schedule, however, epistemic beliefs were being investigated at all three datapoints. It is understandable that participants would draw on or reflect upon their FYP experience when responding to questions about the nature of knowledge and knowing, or useful knowledge from ITE, during the DP3 Interview.
Accordingly, it is expected, that a larger volume of comments surrounding the FYP would be noted in DP2. The interview schedule is provided in the Appendix, showing variations in components for all three data points. The interviews were multicomponent in nature so as to elicit epistemic beliefs in different ways, because individuals often find it difficult to articulate their epistemic beliefs (Guilfoyle, 2022; Joram, 2007). The different components offered a range of opportunities to demonstrate or reveal beliefs (e.g., by discussing learning experiences and aspirations for teaching), to consider alternative perspectives through concept cartoons (Naylor et al., 2007) or to respond to very direct questions on epistemic issues (Tsai, 2002).
The interview also utilised cognitive interviewing strategies (Greene et al., 2010) with Hofer’s (2000) Discipline-Focused Epistemic Belief Questionnaire (DFEBQ) to gain deeper understanding about PSTs’ epistemic beliefs with respect to the theoretical dimensions of epistemic beliefs (Hofer, 2000). The DFEBQ contains 21 Likert scale items for each discipline with statements such as ‘Truth is unchanging in this subject’ and ‘Correct answers in this field are more a matter of opinion than fact’. The Table 1 Dimensions of Epistemic Beliefs (Synthesis, adapted from Guilfoyle, 2018). Dimension Indicators Polar End (1) Nuanced Position (3) Polar End (2) Certainty [C] Certain: Fixed, stable, concrete, unchanging, undoubted, everyone would have the same answer.
Certain to varying degrees, depending on the discipline and area. Core and peripheral knowledge. Uncertain: Fluid, tentative, evolving, changing, best we know at the time. Structure [St] Simple: Discrete, straight-forward, concrete facts. Isolated, unrelated, accumulated. Generally, beliefs about knowledge as more complex than simple are preferable. Complex: Relative and contingent on other concepts. Inter-related and connected. Universal [U]: Knowledge is (or aims to be) applicable globally regardless of context. Knowledge is generated in context, but can be generalised by various means, including transferability to similar contexts. Particularistic: Knowledge is (or aims to be) specific to the context in which it was generated.
Justification [J] Authority/ expertise: ‘Because an expert said so’ - Unwavering trust in authority. Evaluation and integration of expert views and evidence. Personal experience: Because of personal experience, intuition, or evaluation of evidence. Source [So] Outside the self: From expert, authority source – e.g., teacher, scientist, book etc. Recognising multiple sources can support a claim. Within the Self: From experience, intuition, own investigation L. Guilfoyle et al. 5participants responded to each statement, but only selected responses were probed further. Responses were selected if they were particularly notable, such as responding on opposite ends of the scale for science vs Education Studies.
In addition to the full questions provided in the appendix, Table 4 outlines the different components of the interview, their purpose, content, and changes across datapoints.
2.4. Analysis
We approached this research question in a qualitative manner which sought to understand the connections and changes in a holistic and multifaceted way in the context of participants experiences (Pettigrew, 1995). Underpinned by a critical realist philosophical stance, causation in this study is considered differently from the standard Humean approach of ‘If A happens, then B will happen’ (Sayer, 2010). Rather, there is a recognition that social causation can be considered as ‘processes’ and where a ‘well-constructed story can satisfy us as an explanation of an event’ such that it is ‘reasonable to see’ how one thing leads to another (Becker, 1994, pp.188-189). The goal is ‘to describe credibly, vividly, and persuasively for readers through appropriate narrative the processes of participant change through time’ (Saldana, p.46).
We therefore used individual narrative profiles in both the analysis and presentation of findings (Seidman, 2006). The analysis followed the following steps: (1) Coding: First, all transcripts were subject to both inductive and deductive coding for the perceptions and beliefs of interest, focusing on both latent and semantic meanings (Clarke & Braun, 2014). All instances of epistemic beliefs were identified using an expanded version of Table 1. Statements would be coded depending on the dimension (e.g., Certainty of knowledge, abbreviation [C], see Table 1) and domain (e.g., science or Education Studies) to which they were relevant. For example, the statement ‘in science there is an end. There is a right answer’, would be coded as relevant to the dimension of ‘certainty’ in the domain of science.
We did not seek to reduce the beliefs to ‘naïve’ or ‘sophisticated’ that we recognise is traditionally the case in epistemic beliefs research, because we know that beliefs are more complex than this (Sinatra, 2016). We endeavoured to capture and represent this complexity. Therefore, we discuss development not in terms of movement from a category of ‘naïve’ to ‘sophisticated’ but a change in particular beliefs (e.g., from believing that all knowledge in science is certain, to believing that there is some knowledge that is more certain than others). (2) Generating Profiles: Using the coded elements for each participant, individual belief profiles (in narrative form) were produced to capture a holistic view of the participants’ thoughts, including contradictory/contrasting beliefs and the context for their beliefs (e.g., if talking about their own teaching or learning, or in reference to particular experiences such as school placement or research projects). (3) Considering Change: These profiles also captured how some beliefs changed over time.
These changes in beliefs are recognised in two ways, first by noting the presence of different beliefs in subsequent time points and the second is by noting the individual’s statements about how their thinking has changed. Segments of data pertaining to participants’ research experiences were drawn out to generate some descriptive accounts of such experiences. Again, we consider both how these experiences coexist with any relative change in epistemic beliefs (e.g., DP1 statement, vs DP2 statement), but we also specifically consider how participants themselves note their beliefs changing as a result of, or while engaging in, particular activities (e.g., I used to think … now I think …). (4) Manageable and meaningful reporting: Full profiles consisted about 12 pages of text per participant per time point, including quotations and interpretations.
These require further reduction to make them manageable and meaningful (Luker, 2009); therefore, what is presented in this paper are demonstrative extracts and summaries rather than full profiles for each individual. For this paper, we focused our attention only on discussion which could be related to their experience of engaging in research. We acknowledge that many other experiences in ITE could be influential for participants, however discussion of their engagement in research projects generated rich reflection of their epistemic beliefs worthy of further analysis. Table 2 Extracts from university module outlines. Module Heading Semester 7 – Final Year Project 1 Semester 8 – Final Year Project 2 Syllabus: Introduction to the project; definition of its purpose, scope, requisites.
Introduction to methodologies for undertaking primary and secondary research. Development of initial thesis and research design; directives for refining the initial research idea and for conducting research. Collection and analysis of primary data, as required. Guidance on the formats available for the final report, on the analytical approaches required, and on the methodology and documentation. Learning Outcomes: ⁃ Identify literature relevant to the selected research project. ⁃ Define a research topic. ⁃ Interpret and review the literature relevant to the research question. ⁃ Value the significance of the contribution of research to solving problems. ⁃ Deliver analysis of refereed research papers to peers. ⁃ Organise and present in written format the secondary data and research findings relevant to the research question. ⁃ Arrange, collect and examine published literature on a selected research topic ⁃ Clarify, defend and interpret the literature and data available on the research topic ⁃ Apply the available information relevant to the research topic to solve the research questions and problems ⁃ Summarise and synthesise the findings of the research effort ⁃ Analyse the outcomes and draw conclusions from the findings of the relevant primary and secondary data available ⁃ Evaluate the findings and recommend further action/directions of study. ⁃ Acknowledge the contribution of the research work to furthering knowledge and understanding, skills and attitudes as these relate to the research project ⁃ Undertake primary data collection, as required. ⁃ Compile the total research process into a dissertation reflective of the prescribed requirements.
Learning Experiences Not Stated Not Stated Credits (of 240 Total) 6 6 L. Guilfoyle et al.
62.5. Quality criteria
We subscribed to a vision of quality criteria for qualitative research as articulated by Tracy (2010). This vision builds on the shift in attention away from concepts of reliability, validity, and generalizability (from quantitative research) to criteria of credibility, transferability, and dependability for qualitative research (Lincoln & Guba, 1985). Rather than inter-rater reliability, which generates a measure of how often we agree on the application of a particular coding label, we focused on interrogating the appropriateness of the inferences at each step but particularly at the point of producing individual belief profiles (asking whether the evidence presented was sufficient to make such claims about the participant).
Throughout this process, the second and third authors acted as ‘critical friends’ who question, critique, and probe in an effort to attain ‘interpretive agreement’ (Tappan, 1997) and check inferences/connections being drawn (Stieha, 2014).
3. Results
The findings of this paper are presented with respect to the different types of research experiences in which the participants engaged; these are research experiences in science, in Education Studies (including science education), and further scientific research beyond ITE. Finally, we reflect on the absence of explicit epistemological development during the research experiences and in ITE more generally. As outlined in the analysis section, we present the results in a narrative form to ‘describe credibly, vividly, and persuasively for readers’ (Saldana, 2003, p. 46) such that it is ‘reasonable to see’ the impact of the various experiences for these participants (Becker, 1994, pp.188-189). Accordingly, each participant’s experience is summarised as interpreted by the researchers, with supportive and illustrative quotes.
Rather than claiming that particular experiences will regularly cause particular outcomes, these narrative profiles explore plausible possibilities for the role these research experiences can play in PSTs’ epistemological development. Table 3 Summary of research projects. Pseudonym Discipline of Project Brief Description of Project Notes on the experience Harvey Science – Biology Identification of organisms in urban ecosystems to draw conclusions about environmental health/quality. Largely independent field-based work. Guidance provided by supervisor, particularly for asking questions of methods and interpreting results. Lisa Science – Biology Analysis of soil content to draw conclusions about environmental health/quality.
Both field and labbased work. Working alongside masters and PhD students in the lab, who provide some guidance and training. Supervisor support was available. But there was still a feeling that independence and that personal initiative was necessary. Haley Science – Biochemistry + Further Research Post ITE Molecular cloning to produce a particular protein. Working as part of a group, continuing from previous students’ work. Support for methods and skills provided through the research group and the supervisor. Bruce Education Studies Psychology-informed mixed method study of teachers’ perceptions and use of particular educational equipment. Largely independent field work, though with support from supervisor in developing methodology and exploring the relevant literature.
Monica Education Studies Qualitative study on teacher attitudes and preparedness for a given social issue in the school context. Largely independent field work, though with support from supervisor in developing methodology and exploring the relevant literature. Lana Science Education Designing researchinformed educational resources for a particular science topic. Gathering preservice teachers’ understanding and beliefs on the topic and perceptions of the resources. Largely independent desk research in developing resources and field work in higher education setting for surveys with pre-service teachers. Did not emphasise any specific supervisor support. Table 4 Interview components, purposes, content and changes over time.
Component Purpose Content (See
Author contributions
Liam Guilfoyle: Writing – review & editing, Writing – original draft, Methodology, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal analysis, Conceptualization. O. McCormack: Writing – review & editing, Validation, Supervision. S. Erduran: Writing – review & editing, Validation, Supervision.
Funding
Irish Research Council (GOIPG/2016/1071)
Declaration of competing interest
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence the work reported in this paper.
Acknowledgements
Funding: This work was supported by the Irish Research Council. [GOIPG/2016/1071].
Data availability
The data that has been used is confidential.
References
- 1Ball (1990). The subject-matter preparation of teachers.
- 2Becker (1994). "Foi por Acaso": Conceptualizing Coincidence. The Sociological Quarterly, 35, 183. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1533-8525.1994.tb00406.x
- 3(2014). Research and the Teaching Profession: Building the capacity for a self-improving education system.
- 4Bondy (2007). Personal epistemologies and learning to teach.
- 5Bråten (2016). Epistemic cognition interventions: Issues, challenges, and directions.
- 6Bråten (2011). The role of epistemic beliefs in the comprehension of multiple expository texts: Toward an integrated model. Educational Psychologist, 46, 48. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2011.538647
- 7Brew (2020). Making sense of research-based learning in teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 87. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2019.102935
- 8Brown (2007). Preservice teachers' research experiences in scientists' laboratories. Journal of Science Teacher Education, 18, 573. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10972-007-9044-9
- 9Brownlee (2011).
- 10Brownlee (2016). Changes in preservice teachers' personal epistemologies.
- 11Buehl (2016). The role of epistemic cognition in teacher learning and praxis.
- 12Chinn (2011). Expanding the dimensions of epistemic cognition: Arguments from philosophy and psychology. Educational Psychologist, 46, 141. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2011.587722
- 13Clarke (2014). Thematic analysis.
- 14Cochran-Smith (2009).
- 15Conway (2009).
- 16Darling-Hammond (2006). Constructing 21st-century teacher education. Journal of Teacher Education, 57, 300. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487105285962
- 17Darling-Hammond (2010). Teacher education and the American future. Journal of Teacher Education, 61, 35. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487109348024
- 18Drever (1999). Students' use of theory in an initial teacher education programme. Journal of Education for Teaching, 25, 97. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607479919574
- 19Elby (2016). Epistemic cognition in science.
- 20Erduran (2014).
- 21Feiman-Nemser (2012).
- 22Fives (2011). One preservice teacher's developing personal epistemology about teaching and the explicit connection of those beliefs to future practice.
- 23Flores (2016). Teacher education curriculum.
- 24Furlong (2013).
- 25Furlong (2017). Knowledge traditions in the study of education.
- 26Gill (2004). Changing preservice teachers' epistemological beliefs about teaching and learning in mathematics: An intervention study. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 29, 164. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cedpsych.2004.01.003
- 27Gottlieb (2012). Between veritas and communitas: Epistemic switching in the reading of academic and sacred history. The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 21, 84. https://doi.org/10.1080/10508406.2011.582376
- 28Greene (2010). Using cognitive interviewing to explore elementary and secondary school students' epistemic and ontological cognition.
- 29Guilfoyle (2018).
- 30Guilfoyle (2022). Cognitive and multicomponent interviewing.
- 31Guilfoyle (2020). The "tipping point" for educational research: The role of pre-service science teachers' epistemic beliefs in evaluating the professional utility of educational research. Teaching and Teacher Education, 90.
- 32Hardoim (2014). Narrativas de iniciação à docência na relação universidade-escola.
- 33Healey (2009). Developing undergraduate research and inquiry.
- 34Hofer (2000). Dimensionality and disciplinary differences in personal epistemology. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 25, 378. https://doi.org/10.1006/ceps.1999.1026
- 35Hofer (2016). Epistemic cognition as a psychological construct: Advancements and challenges.
- 36Hofer (1997). The development of epistemological theories: Beliefs about knowledge and knowing and their relation to learning. Review of Educational Research, 67, 88. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543067001088
- 37Hökkä (2013). Seeking new perspectives on the development of teacher education: A study of the Finnish context. Journal of Teacher Education, 65, 39. https://doi.org/10.1177/0022487113504220
- 38Hordern (2017). Berstein's sociology of knowledge and educational(al) studies.
- 39Iordanou (2010). Developing argument skills across scientific and social domains. Journal of Cognition and Development, 11, 293. https://doi.org/10.1080/15248372.2010.485335
- 40Iordanou (2014). Developing pre-service teachers' evidence-based argumentation skills on socio-scientific issues. Learning and Instruction, 34, 42. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.learninstruc.2014.07.004
- 41Jacobson (1995). Hypertext learning environments, cognitive flexibility, and the transfer of complex knowledge: An empirical investigation. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 12, 301. https://doi.org/10.2190/4T1B-HBP0-3F7E-J4PN
- 42Joram (2007). Clashing epistemologies: Aspiring teachers', practicing teachers', and professors' beliefs about knowledge and research in education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 23, 123. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2006.04.032
- 43Joram (2020). What influences teachers' “buy-in” of research? Teachers' beliefs about the applicability of educational research to their practice. Teaching and Teacher Education, 88. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2019.102980
- 44Jorde (2017). Building science teacher identity within an integrated teacher education program at the University of Oslo.
- 45Kitchen (2016). Approaches to teacher education.
- 46Korthagen (1999). Linking theory and practice: Changing the pedagogy of teacher education. Educational Researcher, 28, 4. https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X028004004
- 47Krim (2019). Models and impacts of science research experiences: A review of the literature of CUREs, UREs, and TREs. CBE-Life Sciences Education, 18, ar65. https://doi.org/10.1187/cbe.19-03-0069
- 48Lapostolle (2011). Teacher training in France in the early 2010s. Journal of Education for Teaching, 37, 451. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607476.2011.611014
- 49Lederman (2007). Nature of science: Past, present, future.
- 50Lincoln (1985).
- 51Löfström (2015). Knowledge and knowing in mathematics and pedagogy: A case study of mathematics student teachers epistemological beliefs. Teachers and Teaching: Theory and Practice, 21, 527. https://doi.org/10.1080/13540602.2014.995476
- 52Loughran (2016).
- 53Luft (2007). Capturing science teachers' epistemological beliefs: The development of the teacher beliefs interview. Electronic Journal of Science Education, 11, 38.
- 54Luker (2009).
- 55Mason (2010). Beliefs about knowledge and revision of knowledge: On the importance of epistemic beliefs for intentional conceptual change in elementary and middle school students.
- 56McGarr (2017). Exploring the theory-practice gap in initial teacher education: Moving beyond questions of relevance to issues of power and authority. Journal of Education for Teaching, 43, 48. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607476.2017.1256040
- 57Medwell (2014). Pre-service teachers undertaking classroom research: Developing reflection and enquiry skills. Journal of Education for Teaching, 40, 65. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607476.2013.864018
- 58Merk (2017). Pre-service teachers' perceived value of general pedagogical knowledge for practice: Relations with epistemic beliefs and source beliefs. PLoS One, 12, 1. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0184971
- 59Muis (2007). The role of epistemic beliefs in self-regulated learning. Educational Psychologist, 42, 173. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520701416306
- 60Munthe (2011). Teacher education reform and challenges in Norway. Journal of Education for Teaching, 37, 441. https://doi.org/10.1080/02607476.2011.611012
- 61Naylor (2007). Argumentation and primary science. Research in Science Education, 37, 17. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11165-005-9002-5
- 62Niemi (2014). Research studies and active learning promoting professional competences in Finnish teacher education. Teaching and Teacher Education, 43, 131. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2014.07.006
- 63O' Doherty (2016). Teacher education in the republic of Ireland: A challenging and changing landscape.
- 64Peiser (2022). Student teachers' views about the university's research contribution to professional knowledge development. Teaching and Teacher Education, 112. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.tate.2022.103647
- 65Pettigrew (1995). Longitudinal field research on change: Theory and practice.
- 66Sahlberg (2011).
- 67Saldana (2003).
- 68Sayer (2010).
- 69Schommer-Aikins (2002). An evolving theoretical framework for an epistemological belief system.
- 70Schwab (1962). The teaching of science as enquiry.
- 71Schwartz (2004). Developing views of nature of science in an authentic context: An explicit approach to bridging the gap between nature of science and scientific inquiry. Science Education, 88, 610. https://doi.org/10.1002/sce.10128
- 72Seidman (2006).
- 73Sinatra (2016). Thoughts on knowledge about thinking about knowledge.
- 74Sjølie (2014). The role of theory in teacher education: Reconsidered from a student teacher perspective. Journal of Curriculum Studies, 46, 729. https://doi.org/10.1080/00220272.2013.871754
- 75Sozbilir (2007). First steps in educational research: The views of Turkish chemistry and biology student teachers. European Journal of Teacher Education, 30, 41. https://doi.org/10.1080/02619760601120072
- 76Stanovich (1986). Matthew effects in reading: Some consequences of individual differences in the acquisition of literacy. Reading Research Quarterly, 21, 360. https://doi.org/10.1598/RRQ.21.4.1
- 77Stieha (2014). Critical friend.
- 78Tappan (1997). Interpretive psychology: Stories, circles, and understanding lived experience. Journal of Social Issues, 53, 645. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-4560.1997.tb02453.x
- 79Tatto (2015). Research and teacher education: Papers from the BERA-RSA inquiry. Oxford Review of Education, 41, 145. https://doi.org/10.1080/03054985.2015.1017404
- 80(2017). Initial teacher education: Criteria and guidelines for programme providers.
- 81(2020).
- 82Tracy (2010). Qualitative quality: Eight “Big-Tent” criteria for excellent qualitative research. Qualitative Inquiry, 16, 837. https://doi.org/10.1177/1077800410383121
- 83Tripney.
- 84Tsai (2002). Nested epistemologies: Science teachers' beliefs of teaching, learning and science. International Journal of Science Education, 24, 771. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500690110049132
- 85Urhahne (2023). Specificity of epistemic beliefs across school subject domains. Educational Psychology, 43, 99. https://doi.org/10.1080/01443410.2023.2179605
- 86Walker (2012). A longitudinal study of change in preservice teachers' personal epistemologies. Australian Journal of Teacher Education, 37. https://doi.org/10.14221/ajte.2012v37n5.1
- 87Yilmaz-Tuzun (2008). Relationships among preservice science teachers' epistemological beliefs, epistemological world views, and self-efficacy beliefs. International Journal of Science Education, 30, 65. https://doi.org/10.1080/09500690601185113
There are no recommended articles yet.
Only verified metrics entered by the editorial office are shown. Values marked “Not available” have not been measured yet.
- Views
- Not available
- Downloads
- Not available
- Citations
- 18
Source: Crossref cited-by count, 2026-11-17

