Research articleOpen access
Berber N. Langelaan, Lisa Gaikhorst, Wouter Smets, Ron J. Oostdam
Primary and secondary school teachers are expected to adapt their teaching to the diverse educational needs of students through differentiated instruction (DI). This review included 29 peer-reviewed published articles from 2010 to 2020 evaluating the contribution of preservice and in-service teacher programs for DI. We synthesized program components, outcomes and contextual interplay. Results indicate that successful programs incorporate active learning, collaboration and reflection and were often longitudinal, comprehensive and addressed attitudes, knowledge and skills. Contextual (school) factors acted as facilitators and impediments to program efficacy. Balancing school ambitions with realistic expectations is a concern. Educational and policy implications are further discussed.
Research articleOpen access
Nataša Pantić, Marc Sarazin, Thibault Coppe, Didem Oral, Eveliina Manninen, Kaisa Silvennoinen, Anna Lund, Hökkä Päivi, Katja Vähäsantanen, Shupin Li
This study examines how teachers exercise relational agency - working flexibly with other actors in their social networks to support migrant students. Teachers and other staff members from 7 schools in Scotland, Finland and Sweden participated in social network surveys (n = 1116), online logs (n = 275) and interviews (n = 82). A mixed-method social network analysis shows how networks facilitate relational agency as teachers reach out to others to mobilise resources and tacit knowledge within their school communities. The findings point to the critical role of professional collaboration and suggest that social networks shape how teachers work with specialists to support migrant students.
Research articleOpen access
Thibault Coppe, Michaël Parmentier, Geert Kelchtermans, Isabel Raemdonck, Virginie März, Stéphane Colognesi
We argue that overlooking teacher professional development's (TPD) temporal and spatial situatedness neglects similarities and differences throughout teachers' career stages and organizational contexts. Using latent profile analyses for early-career (n = 383), mid-career (n = 355), and late-career (n = 296) teacher groups, we found four TPD profiles in each career phase. Results showed more heterogeneity of profiles within than between career phases; most early-career teachers shared common TPD patterns with other career phases. Throughout the phases, teachers need TPD addressing their work at both the classroom and organizational levels. Our research invites researchers to rethink reductionist narratives regarding TPD.
Research articleOpen access
Rebecca M. Tickell, Robert M. Klassen
As a psychometrically robust scale for measuring teacher mentoring self-efficacy beliefs remains to be established, the purpose of this study was to address this gap by developing the teacher mentoring self-efficacy scale (TMSES). In Phase 1 a Delphi approach (N = 26) determined the competencies needed for effective teacher mentoring. In Phase 2 these 44 competencies were used to generate TMSES items. Following testing with 239 teacher mentors, exploratory factor analysis suggested a 16-item two-factor model, with factors named as ‘Pedagogical Practices’ and ‘Professional Relationships.’ Results suggested strong inter-connections between qualitative themes, quantitative factors, and the theorised sources of self-efficacy.
Research articleOpen access
Sotiria Varis, Mirva Heikkilä, Riitta-Leena Metsäpelto, Mirjamaija Mikkilä-Erdmann
Amidst the broad range of teacher competencies, professional beliefs and professional identity are two important domains of personal orientations that inform teacher quality. This study examines how pre-service teachers have negotiated their professional identity after their first year in initial primary teacher education. The study uses qualitative data from an online survey voluntarily answered by seventy-two Finnish pre-service teachers in Spring 2022. The data were thematically analyzed and further examined for additive, transformative, and defensive identity development using Ruohotie-Lyhty's (2018) framework of teachers' identity-agency. The study supports the notion of identity as social, multiple, and discontinuous.
Research articleOpen access
İpek Gülsün, Olli-Pekka Malinen, Akie Yada, Hannu Savolainen
Using a sample of 384 Finnish teachers, in this study we explored how teachers' attitudes towards inclusive education, self-efficacy, and collective efficacy in behaviour management affect their behaviours in teaching appropriate behaviours to students, and how teachers' attitudes, self-efficacy, and collective efficacy mediate the effect of background variables on teacher behaviour. The results revealed that teachers’ self-efficacy and collective efficacy significantly predicted their behaviour. The number of students with attention or behavioural problems has an indirect negative effect on teacher behaviour, mediated by teacher self-efficacy.
Research articleOpen access
Päivi Kupila, Elina Fonsén, Tarja Liinamaa
In this study, we explore the discourses and dilemmas embodying Finnish early childhood education leaders' expectations regarding their leadership. The data were collected in three focus group interviews with leaders in three municipalities. Four discourses were identified: the discourse of leadership in change, the discourse of leading an expert organisation towards a vision, the discourse of leadership style, and the discourse of leading the ECE mission. Contextual change is the framework in which expectations occur. Leaders experience many dilemmas affecting their leadership. The dilemmas focused on leading change in the administrative hierarchy, leading an expert organisation, approachability, and leading according to one's mission. Leaders themselves should identify the dilemmas. Strengthening leadership in a changing work context requires the identification of dilemmas.
Research articleOpen access
Auli Lehtinen, Emma Kostiainen, Piia Näykki
Building on social constructivist theory, this case study analyzed how pre-service secondary teachers co-constructed knowledge and expressed socioemotional interaction in online breakout rooms during a collaborative task. Video data was analyzed by content and interaction analysis. There was more higher-level knowledge construction than in most studies from asynchronous settings. Active listening and humor were thoroughly present. Talk about personal experiences occurred at both lower and higher levels of thinking. The teacher educator's visits to the breakout rooms and purposeful dissonance affected knowledge co-construction and socioemotional interaction. The findings will help in designing high-quality online and blended teacher education.
Research articleOpen access
Blaine B. Taylor, Mattias Wingren, Anette Bengs, Heidi Katz, Emmanuel Acquah
This study explored educators' perceptions of preparatory education and integration training for immigrants in Finland. It included twelve semi-structured interviews of teachers working with adult or child immigrants. A thematic analysis identified: 1. Variances in students' knowledge, skill, and experience complicate integration; 2. Flexibility, the ability to alter classwork to suit students' needs, and the lack of preparatory support or relevant materials in diverse classrooms are problematic; 3. Adult immigrants’ perception as workers, not students, results in a disconnect between expectations. A holistic/ecological approach to addressing the challenges is required to support integration and inclusion better.
Research articleOpen access
Katarzyna Kärkkäinen, Päivikki Jääskelä, Päivi Tynjälä
Through a literature review, this study identified research themes related to university pedagogy and examined how these themes appear in the curricula of university pedagogy courses and in the experiences of the participants and trainers of these courses at a Finnish research university. The literature review produced a multidimensional model of the relationships between identified themes, which can be used as an analytical tool for examining pedagogical training. Analysis of the courses revealed a need to broaden the understanding of the course contents and practices and their alignment to global, societal, and labour-market needs.
Research articleOpen access
Christopher Neil Prilop, Kira Elena Weber
We investigate the effects of peer feedback training (enhanced by expert feedback) on pre-service teachers’ feedback quality and beliefs. Intervention group 1 (IG1) analysed classroom videos before the feedback training, while intervention group 2 (IG2) additionally received expert feedback on their video analyses. IG1 and IG2 were compared to a control group (CG). Results show pre-service teachers in IG1 and IG2 improved their peer feedback quality and beliefs in comparison to the CG. Expert feedback (IG2) lead to greater increases of peer feedback quality than without (IG1). This study highlights the role of expert feedback when training peer feedback.
Research articleOpen access
Laura Ketonen, Juuso Henrik Nieminen
Reflection is a key learning objective of teacher education, yet little is known about the ways in which it could be supported through assessment. In this case study (N = 14), we examine the potential of a novel assessment task—reflective podcasting—in supporting first-year student teachers’ reflection. We analyzed student group podcasts and corresponding student reflections and found that the task engendered reflection. Three theory-driven dimensions were constructed to emphasize the unique nature of podcasts for student reflection: experientiality, authenticity, and communality. We encourage factoring these dimensions into assessment designs that seek to foster student reflection.
Research articleOpen access
Uta Klusmann, Karen Aldrup, Janina Roloff-Bruchmann, Bastian Carstensen, Gyde Wartenberg, Julia Hansen, Reiner Hanewinkel
We aimed to identify the levels of and changes in emotional exhaustion experienced by teachers and principals during the COVID-19 pandemic and pandemic-related stressors and resources. In a German sample of 2157 teachers and 374 principals, we found high levels and an increase of emotional exhaustion. Results from multi-group structural equation modeling analyses indicated that health concerns and workload were positively and social support negatively related to emotional exhaustion. Additional analyses of an open response question confirmed that teachers and principals experienced their work during the COVID-19 pandemic as predominantly stressful. These results indicate the importance of supporting both teachers and principals in reducing their exhaustion to help students overcome the consequences of the COVID-19 pandemic.
Research articleOpen access
Heli Muhonen, Eija Pakarinen, Marja-Kristiina Lerkkanen
This study investigated Grade 2 teachers' (N = 50) professional vision through eye-tracking methodology and retrospective think-aloud interviews. The study examined the extent to which teachers' knowledge-based reasoning explains their visual focus of attention to whole class and individual students. We found that teachers' descriptions of students' social relations and emotions associated positively with teachers' visual focus of attention to the whole class. Teachers' descriptions of teacher-related information/elaboration and pedagogy linked negatively with teachers' visual focus of attention to individual students. The findings suggest that teachers' visual focus of attention to students may vary depending on the reasons that guide teachers’ attention.
Research articleOpen access
Iris Uffen, Siebrich de Vries, Sui Lin Goei, Klaas van Veen, Nellie Verhoef
Although lesson study (LS) is widely considered a promising approach to teachers' professional development, the variation in teacher learning in LS is not yet well understood. Using a cultural–historical activity theory lens, we identify aspects of LS as a learning activity of significance for teacher learning. Using mixed-methods analysis of questionnaire and interview data drawn from 17 secondary school teachers, we find multiple variables of relevance in relation to teacher learning. This study clearly shows that participants’ understanding of and attitude toward LS are at least as important as how LS is conducted.
Research articleOpen access
Muhammad Fauzan Ansyari, Wim Groot, Kristof De Witte
This paper reports on teachers' preferences for online professional development programmes in Indonesia. Relying on data from 330 university English teachers, the results of our discrete choice experiment suggest a significant positive preference for synchronous interaction but a negative preference for costly programmes, programmes offering no certificates of participation or completion, conducted over a longer period and using digital reading materials on teachers' preferences. Subgroup analyses also show that age, gender and experience with online professional development programmes influence teachers’ preferences. Based on these findings, implications for the design of online professional development and gaps for future research are discussed.
Research articleOpen access
Emma Towers, Sharon Gewirtz, Meg Maguire, Eszter Neumann
There has been a tendency to construct the teaching profession through a narrative of ‘crisis’ which places particular emphasis on high rates of attrition and poor wellbeing driven by a demanding work culture. Drawing on qualitative data from a mixed-methods study, this paper examines teachers' responses to reforms to English secondary education. It presents evidence that supports a ‘profession in crisis’ narrative with many of the research participants expressing negative attitudes towards the reforms and concerns about staying in teaching. However, the paper also illuminates a counter-narrative that highlights teachers' job satisfaction and their desire to remain in the profession.
Research articleOpen access
Huub Oattes, Arie Wilschut, Ron Oostdam, Ruben Fukkink, Rick de Graaff
Teaching history requires clear, detailed and subject specific language. History teachers teaching in a second language are confronted with students' second language limitations, which likely have an aggravating impact on their application of pedagogical content knowledge (PCK). We analysed and compared 12 Dutch spoken and 12 English spoken paired history lessons in junior grades 7 and 9. Contrary to our expectation, we found a strong similarity of the teachers’ PCK application in both grades 7 and 9, irrespective of the used language. The PCK application in both grades and languages was of average quality, while the PCK used in grade 9 was more advanced.
Research articleOpen access
Pei-Hsin Li, Diane Mayer, Lars-Erik Malmberg
Given the high stress and attrition rate among teachers, there is a need to expand knowledge on situational experiences that contribute to teacher well-being. We investigated the links between student lesson-specific behaviour (disruptive behaviour, engagement), teachers' lesson-specific (positive, negative) emotions, daily (morning and end-of-working), and personal general well-being of 20 Taiwanese primary school teachers using a micro-longitudinal approach. By specifying multilevel structural equation models (MSEM), we found student behaviour predicts teachers' lesson-specific emotions, and this association varied across days and teachers. Teachers' lesson-specific positive emotions predict teachers’ well-being, suggesting positive emotions can be a protective factor for teachers.
Research articleOpen access
Geerte M. Savenije, Bjorn G.J. Wansink, Albert Logtenberg
Teaching about the topic of Islam may be challenging. We report the results of a survey study (N = 81) of Dutch history teachers and six in-depth interviews examining the sensitivities experienced when teaching Islam-related issues and the motives that underlie teachers' decisions. We developed an analytical framework comprising three dimensions that describe the proximity and distance between teachers and students from interpersonal, identity and knowledge perspectives. Our results show that differences between teachers and students regarding their sources of knowledge and epistemological authority are an important factor affecting the sensitivity of Islam-related issues.